Wikipedia talk:Requests for adminship/Protonk
Appearance
User:Protonk run at Wed Oct 15 00:44:35 2008 GMT Category talk: 7 Category: 9 Image talk: 3 Image: 16 Mainspace 2846 MediaWiki talk: 7 Talk: 1025 Template talk: 23 Template: 56 User talk: 1203 User: 223 Wikipedia talk: 391 Wikipedia: 2526 avg edits per page 2.50 earliest 04:21, 17 April 2008 number of unique pages 3331 total 8335 2008/4 619 2008/5 166 2008/6 462 2008/7 2049 2008/8 2750 2008/9 1802 2008/10 487 Mainspace 147 Mathematical economics 90 Warhammer 40,000 51 John Emilius Fauquier 43 Los Angeles class submarine 31 Richard A. Houghten 31 Cheshire Cat in popular culture 27 Bloody Sunday (1969) 27 James Wesley Rawles 27 Alvin E. Roth 25 Galaxy Quest 21 Submarine 19 Gary Coleman 19 Panic of 1907 18 Patrick Tyler 17 Adam Smith Talk: 33 Encyclopedia Dramatica 26 James Wesley Rawles 26 4chan 26 Mathematical economics 23 Adam Smith 22 Sports Chiropractic 22 Tulip mania 19 Charlie Crist 17 Los Angeles class submarine 17 Adam Smith/GA1 16 Galaxy Quest 14 Larry Craig 14 Richard A. Houghten 13 Mr Creosote 12 Deletionpedia Category: 3 List-Class Economics articles 3 NA-importance Economics articles Image: 2 Bloody Sunday 1969.jpg 2 VCCGB.png 2 John Fauquier.jpg 2 Smith medallion portrait.jpg Image talk: 2 Corbata roja.jpg MediaWiki talk: 4 Spam-whitelist 2 Uploadtext Template: 8 Warhammer 40,000 Project 5 WikiProject September 11, 2001 4 WikiProject Economics 3 Warhammer-40,000-stub 3 User WikiProject Warhammer 40,000 2 Economics 2 Warhammer 40,000 Template talk: 14 Did you know 6 Film 2 Warhammer-40,000-stub User: 103 Protonk 16 Protonk/Rescued 15 Protonk/NAC 11 Protonk/math 8 Protonk/Barnstars 7 NickPenguin/temp 6 Protonk/stats 5 Protonk/To do 4 Petercorless/Carpent tua poma nepotes 4 Protonk/monobook.js 4 Protonk/FPC 3 Casliber/Airplanes in popular culture 3 Protonk/huggle.css 3 Tealwisp/Space Marine Chapters 2 GoldDragon/Weapons of the Imperium (Warhammer 40,000) User talk: 195 Protonk 97 Keeper76 67 Allemandtando 34 A Nobody 17 DGG 13 Benjiboi 12 Tealwisp/Space Marine Chapters 10 Inclusionist 10 Rossusna02 10 MiltonP Ottawa 10 A Man In Black 9 Thumperward 9 Future Perfect at Sunrise 7 Cretog8 7 PennySeven Wikipedia: 234 Reliable sources/Noticeboard 105 Administrators' noticeboard/Incidents 72 Good article nominations 71 Administrators' noticeboard 59 Administrator intervention against vandalism 37 WikiProject Warhammer 40,000 26 Articles for deletion/Space Battleship Yamato (spaceship) (2nd nomination) 25 Notability/RFC:compromise 19 Articles for deletion/Log/2008 September 6 18 Articles for deletion/Cheshire Cat in popular culture (2nd nomination) 18 Articles for deletion/Goatse.cx (5th nomination) 18 Articles for deletion/Log/2008 September 1 17 Articles for deletion/United Airlines in popular culture 16 WikiProject Warhammer 40,000/Templates 15 Articles for deletion/Hema Sinha (2nd nomination) Wikipedia talk: 66 Articles for deletion 47 Article Rescue Squadron 32 WikiProject Economics 28 Biographies of living persons 22 Notability/RFC:compromise 22 Deletion policy 20 "In popular culture" articles 14 WikiProject Warhammer 40,000 13 Notability (fiction) 13 WikiProject Video games 11 Editing restrictions/Civility restrictions 9 Requests for adminship 8 Abuse filter 8 Criteria for speedy deletion 7 Deletion process
Comments moved from oppose section
[edit]- Oppose because the candidate came here with bad intentions (how do we know we’re still not being had?), does not seem to understand how admin boards work and venue shopped/escalated tensions during a dispute (see User_talk:Protonk/Archive_1#Suggestion, User_talk:Protonk/Archive_1#Title_and_3RR, and User_talk:Protonk/Archive_1#RFCs), is too quick to fly off the handle/lose temper for a prospective admin (User_talk:Protonk/Archive_3#Rescue_tag_on_Ultramarines) and while claiming there that he wanted nothing to do with his opponent followed him around anyway as seen in Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion/User:Stormie/DRV notes and apparently was in no hurry even after that to let things be, has been warned for vandalism, and has engaged in edit warring. Also, look at the earliest edits here. His immediately jumping into AfDs is also somewhat unusual for a “new” user.--A Nobody 02:10, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- FYI to curious readers - this editor, A Nobody, is the 3rd name of the editor that Protonk referenced above in his answer to question 3 (conflicts). They have a history of disputes, albeit under the original name of the editor above. You should have no difficulty figuring out his previous names, but he was renamed because of stalking issues (according to him) so I won't say it outright. Avruch T 02:22, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- Yes, please don't as the concerns do remain to some degree. In any event, I do not wish to renew our past conflicts and hope that we will never have any negative future interactions. I am saying here what I feel I need to say after everything and will say no more. I have no wish to pile on or reignite things. Actually, I don't think that's really likely at this point anyway, as I'm not apt to be around much and I definitely don't have time for the areas in which we had run into past conflict any more. I really do not trust him as an admin due to our past experiences, although I always hold out hope that anyone can surprise me, and I have no desire to feel any animosity beyond that. I have said my peace and that is all. --A Nobody 02:30, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- FYI to curious readers - this editor, A Nobody, is the 3rd name of the editor that Protonk referenced above in his answer to question 3 (conflicts). They have a history of disputes, albeit under the original name of the editor above. You should have no difficulty figuring out his previous names, but he was renamed because of stalking issues (according to him) so I won't say it outright. Avruch T 02:22, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- Anyone who isn't lobotomised would know you by that oppose. Interesting that your personal safety is apparently less important to you than opposing in your normal way. Everyme 04:02, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- Be fair. He's renamed. He's in good standing. It doesn't much good to taunt him. Protonk (talk) 04:05, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- Anyone who isn't lobotomised would know you by that oppose. Interesting that your personal safety is apparently less important to you than opposing in your normal way. Everyme 04:02, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- His immediately jumping into AfDs is also somewhat unusual for a “new” user. — So you're basically assuming that he is a sockpuppet of a prior account. Good, nothing better is to expect of you than such baseless allegations. If that's your "peace", I have to say your peace (or piece) sucks ass. Everyme 23:45, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- C'mon Everyme, leave it. He's made his vote, now let him be. How do you turn this on (talk) 23:49, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- You're right. It's just that I reread his oppose and the assumption of bad faith, and particularly the indirect way in which he incorporates that slandering is ugly. Oh so ugly. Everyme 23:54, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- C'mon Everyme, leave it. He's made his vote, now let him be. How do you turn this on (talk) 23:49, 15 October 2008 (UTC)
- His immediately jumping into AfDs is also somewhat unusual for a “new” user. — So you're basically assuming that he is a sockpuppet of a prior account. Good, nothing better is to expect of you than such baseless allegations. If that's your "peace", I have to say your peace (or piece) sucks ass. Everyme 23:45, 15 October 2008 (UTC)