Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/Jerec

Closing administrator's decision rationale

If you choose to add comments to this page, please do so in a new section below, do not inturrupt my comments here.

Raw count analysis

• Delete

1. EEMIV (6 edits) <nominator>
2. Jobjörn
3. Doctorfluffy
4. Gavin.collins
5. Dorftrottel

• Keep

1. RC-0722 (2 edits)
2. Dark Kyle
3. Le Grand Roi des Citrouilles (5 edits)

• Non-participatory

1. The wub (2 edits) - delsort

Valid delete arguments

• notability is not established per WP:FICT
• No assertion of real-world context
• no secondary sources
• Not the subject of multiple, non-trivial published works from sources that are reliable and independent of the subject
• Fails WP:NOT#PLOT

Invalid delete arguments

• previously redirected but reverted by author

Valid keep arguments

• search engine results demonstrated real-world context
  • (many top results were disputed)
• sources should be available for most star wars topics

Invalid keep arguments

• WP:ILIKEIT
• external links can be used as inline citations
  • they do not satisfy WP:RS
• inherits notability from work of fiction in which it appears
• WP:5 pillars allows keeping to improve
  • if notable
• article is organized well
• the article contains factual information
• WP:WAX
• WP:OSE
• WP:INEEDIT
• very important in its fictional universe

Summary

By count and strength of argument this debate is closed as Delete. JERRY ^talk _contribs 02:44, 4 February 2008 (UTC)