Jump to content

Wikipedia:Don't use the VisualEditor

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

The VisualEditor is a great way for new contributors to dive into editing. It allows for new editors to easily make minor changes to articles.

However, for editors who regularly edit Wikipedia, or who want to make significant or complex changes, the VisualEditor comes with serious limitations. Most frequent editors should use the source editor for most edits, using the VisualEditor only for minor or specific kinds of changes.

Differences between the VisualEditor and the source editor

[edit]

The VisualEditor is a bit like Microsoft Word, or a bit like using Wix or GoDaddy to build a website. Just as these tools are great for casual editors, the functionality is limited and often poor for more advanced users. Using the source editor to edit the wikitext markup language on a page provides far more power and control than WYSIWYG editors.

Some problems with the VisualEditor include:

  • misaligning comments in templates
  • changing the format of tables constructed in a specific manner
  • changing spacing in headers without the editor making the change
  • adding extraneous numbers to reference names (see T375306)
  • issues with copying and pasting ISBNs and other identifiers (see T174303 and T162291)
  • deletion of HTML comments (see T247498)

Problems documented with the VisualEditor

[edit]
  • Messing with line breaks after multiline parameters and comments [1]

Making the switch

[edit]

Alternatively, you can enable the source editor inside the VisualEditor, but that can have performance issues for long pages.