User:Fenix down/AfD Arguments
Passes Nfooty just but fails GNG
[edit]*'''Delete''' - one substitute appearances a number years ago (to ''technically'' meet [[WP:NFOOTBALL|NFOOTY]]) is not enough when he comprehensively fails [[WP:GNG|GNG]]. Some [[WP:COMMONSENSE|COMMONSENSE]] is needed here, and plenty of AFD precedent exists to say that barely passing NFOOTBALL is not enough when you fail GNG, see [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Oscar Otazu|Oscar Otazu]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Vyacheslav Seletskiy|Vyacheslav Seletskiy]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Aleksandr Salimov|Aleksandr Salimov]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrei Semenchuk|Andrei Semenchuk]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Artyom Dubovsky|Artyom Dubovsky]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Cosmos Munegabe|Cosmos Munegabe]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Marios Antoniades|Marios Antoniades]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Scott Sinclair (footballer born 1991)|Scott Sinclair]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Fredrik Hesselberg-Meyer (2nd nomination)|Fredrik Hesselberg-Meyer]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Matheus Eccard|Matheus Eccard]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Roland Szabó|Roland Szabó (2nd nomination)]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Metodija Stepanovski|Metodija Stepanovski]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Linas Klimavičius|Linas Klimavičius]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Takumi Ogawa|Takumi Ogawa]], [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Nicky Fish (2nd nomination)|Nicky Fish]] and [[Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Andrei Nițu|Andrei Nițu]], amongst others. ~~~~
Fails NFOOTY and GNG
[edit]*'''Delete''' - Fails [[WP:NFOOTY|NFOOTY]] as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a [[WP:FPL|fully professional league]]. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy [[WP:GNG|GNG]]. ~~~~
*'''Delete both''' - Fail [[WP:NFOOTY|NFOOTY]] as have not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a [[WP:FPL|fully professional league]]. No indication that subjects have garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy [[WP:GNG|GNG]]. ~~~~
*'''Delete all''' - Fail [[WP:NFOOTY|NFOOTY]] as have not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a [[WP:FPL|fully professional league]]. No indication that subjects have garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy [[WP:GNG|GNG]]. ~~~~
Fails NFOOTY and GNG (US Player)
[edit]*'''Delete''' - Fails [[WP:NFOOTY|NFOOTY]] as has not played or managed senior international football nor played or managed in a [[WP:FPL|fully professional league]]. No indication of any collage award to satisfy [[WP:NCOLLATH|NCOLLATH]]. No indication that subject has garnered significant reliable coverage for any other achievements to satisfy either [[WP:NHSPHSATH|NHSPHSATH]] or wider [[WP:GNG|GNG]]. ~~~~
Passes NFOOTY
[edit]*'''Keep''' - Passes [[WP:NFOOTY|NFOOTY]], has played senior international football, in a [[WP:FPL|fully professional league]] or in a match in the competition proper (i.e. not qualifying rounds) of a cup competition which involved two teams both from FPLs. ~~~~
Fails NFOOTY but passes GNG
[edit]*'''Keep''' - Fails [[WP:NFOOTY|NFOOTY]], but passes wider [[WP:GNG|GNG]]. Significant, [[WP:MILL|non-routine]] coverage can be found in the following sources amongst others: :# [] :# [] :# [] :# [] ~~~~
Passes FOOTYN
[edit]*'''Keep''' - Passes [[WP:FOOTYN|FOOTYN]], has played in a national competition. ~~~~
Fails FOOTYN
[edit]*'''Delete''' - fails [[WP:FOOTYN]], no indication the club has played in a national competition, no indication of any other achievements garnering sufficient significant, independent coverage to satisfy GNG. ~~~~
Fails NRIVALRY
[edit]*'''Delete''' - fails [[WP:NRIVALRY]], no evidence of GNG. Simply because two teams play each other regularly does not create a ''de facto'' rivalry. Even if there is a rivalry, it has to be demonstrated that this has received significant, reliable coverage as a notion in itself, not simply the [[WP:SYNTH|synthesis]] of a series of match reports. ~~~~
Fails LISTN
[edit]*'''Delete''' - Per [[WP:LISTN]]; no indication that the list topic has been discussed as a group or set by independent reliable sources. ~~~~