Jump to content

User:DatoShp/sandbox

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Karachay Uprising (1930)

Uprising in Kabardino-Balkaria (1930)

The Karachay Uprising of 1930 was a significant peasant revolt in the Karachay region of the Soviet Union, which was part of the broader resistance to Stalin’s policies of forced collectivization and agricultural reforms. The uprising was characterized by strong opposition from local peasants, especially the kulaks (wealthier peasants) and middle peasants, who rejected the imposition of Soviet policies that stripped them of land, resources, and autonomy. This event is a pivotal episode in Soviet history, reflecting the scale of rural unrest in the North Caucasus during the early years of Stalin’s rule.

Karachay Uprising (1930)
Part of the Russo-Caucasian conflict
DateMarch, 1930
Location
Karachay-Cherkessia Autonomous Oblast, Soviet Union (modern-day Karachay-Cherkessia, Russia)
Result Uprising suppressed
Belligerents
Karachay rebels  Soviet Union
Commanders and leaders
Abulkerim Hasanov
Kady Bayramukov
Islam Baychorov
Isse Mamchuev
Askerbiy Semenov
Ismail Berdiyev		 Sergey Kirov
Semyon Budyonny
Nikolai Yezhov
and local NKVD or military commanders
Units involved
Kulaks: 220
Middle-income peasants: 1,059
Poor peasants: 517		 NKVD
Red Army
local Societ froces
Strength
2,000+ armed rebels
3,000+ unarmed rebels
Overall: around 5,000+ rebels		 Unknown
Casualties and losses
Unknown Unknown

Origins

[edit]

The ethnogenesis of the Karachay-Balkar people is the subject of scholarly debate and involves a complex interplay between indigenous North Caucasian populations, Alans,[1][2][3] and various Turkic nomadic tribes.[2] The question of how Turkic-speaking groups came to inhabit some of the highest regions of the Caucasus, while most other Turkic peoples live on its periphery, has intrigued researchers since the 19th century.[4]

The Karachay-Balkars identify as descendants of the Alans,[5][6][7] asserting that the Alans were originally Turkic-speaking[8][9][10] and that they themselves are not Turkified, but rather preserved the Alanic Turkic language.[11][12][13][14]Ossetians, by contrast, are seen by Karachay-Balkars as descendants of Iranian-speaking settlers from the Sassanid era, a view echoed by 19th-century Iranian scholar Friedrich Spiegel. Spiegel wrote that the Ossetians’ self-name is Iron, and that they descend from Persian military settlers stationed at the Darial Pass, who retained their language after losing contact with the Persian state. He also identified the Balkars as descendants of the western Alans.[15]

In the mid-20th century, the identity and existence of the Karachay-Balkar people were systematically targeted by the Soviet regime. Between 1943 and 1944, the entire population was deported to Central Asia under false accusations of Nazi collaboration.[16] During their exile, lasting until 1957, the USSR attempted to erase them from history—omitting them from official records, destroying books and archives, and changing place names in their homeland.[17]

The 1947 Soviet encyclopedia made no mention of the Balkars, effectively denying their existence.[18] Their Alanic heritage was stripped and reassigned to the Ossetians in Soviet historiography, as Stalin’s regime rewrote not only history but archaeology.[19] Even after their return, the Karachay-Balkars found their homeland divided, their culture suppressed, and their historical presence overwritten—turning the memory of deportation into a central pillar of their modern identity.[16][20]

Historically, several Western travelers and historians identified the Alans as Turkic-speaking.[21] The 13th-century Flemish missionary William of Rubruck, who visited the Caucasus, described the Alans and Cumans as one people and used a Turkic interpreter to speak with them[22][23] The Arab historian Abul-Fida, writing in the 14th century, also referred to the Alans as Turks.[24] Similarly, Ibn Khaldun, in his Kitāb al-ʿIbar, grouped the Alans among Turkic tribes such as the Khazars and Bulgars.[25] Ibn Saʿid al-Maghribī also associated the Alans with Turkic peoples.[26]

European scholars, including the compilers of the 1546 edition of Vitae Caesarum (featuring annotations by Desiderius Erasmus and Baptista Egnatius),[27] Michaelis Antonius (1682),[28] Claude Charles de Peyssonnel (1765),[29][30] R.G. Latham (1854),[31] and the French traveler Jean Chardin (1686),[32] likewise considered the Alans to have Turkic linguistic or ethnic affiliations.

Karachay-Balkars believe that following the Mongol invasions and Tamerlane’s campaigns in the 14th century, surviving Alans retreated into the Caucasus mountains.[33] One such legendary figure, Karcha, a noble Alan who had been held captive in Crimea, is said to have traveled in search of remaining Alans and returned to establish a principality in the North Caucasus. There, he united remnants of Alanian, Caucasian, and Turkic (Khazar, Bulgar, Pecheneg, Kipchak and Cuman) groups. These groups formed the basis of the modern Karachay-Balkar people, with Alanian culture remaining dominant. Karcha is revered as the national hero of the Karachay-Balkars.[34][35][36][9]

Karcha on a horse


The historical use of ethnonyms such as Alans, As, and Bassians to describe Karachay-Balkar ancestors persisted long after the fall of Alania.[37][38] Neighboring peoples and travelers continued to use these terms, while Ossetians were not commonly identified as Alans before the 18th century.[39] Linguist V. I. Abaev emphasized the Alanic substratum in the Karachay-Balkar language as a “firmly established scientific fact.”[40] Ossetian historian G. A. Kokiev likewise acknowledged the close connection between Karachay-Balkars and the Caucasian Alans.[41][42]

Historically, the Karachay-Balkars were frequently labeled as Alans, Bassians, or Caraciole on European and Ottoman maps,[7] while Ossetians were often mentioned separately and only rarely associated with the Alans in cartographic and documentary sources. In some instances, when Karachay-Balkars were identified as Alans on maps, Ossetians were listed as a distinct neighboring group.[43]

Neighboring peoples referred to the Karachay-Balkars using traditional Alanic-related ethnonyms: the Mingrelians and Nogais called them Alans,[44] whereas the Svanetians, as well as Ossetian subgroups such as the Digors and Irons, referred to them as As.[20]

The Alanic heritage remains evident in the modern Karachay-Balkar language, where the word Alan or Alanla is still used to mean “human,” “man,” or “friend,” preserving a direct link to their historical identity.[20]

Additionally, historical sources attest to the use of the ethnonym As among the Alans themselves. The 15th-century Venetian traveler Giosafat Barbaro stated plainly that “the name Alania comes from the people of the Alans, who call themselves As in their own language.”

According to medieval sources, only the closest neighbors of the Ossetians — specifically the Georgians, who fought frequent wars with them and knew them intimately — consistently distinguished between Oseti (the Ossetian lands, centered at the headwaters of the Terek River) and Alaneti (the Alan lands, located at the headwaters of the Kuban River, to the west of the As).

In Guillaume De L’Isle’s 1723 map, the term “Alanes” (Alans) refers to the Karachay-Balkar confederation, highlighting their direct link to the ancient Alans. The labels “Caracioles ou Circasses Noirs” (Karachays or Black Circassians) denote the Karachay-Balkars of the region. Meanwhile, the Ossetians are marked separately as “Grand Oßéti” and “Province d’Oßéti,” indicating a clear recognition of the distinct ethnic and territorial identities within the Caucasus.

The earliest archaeological evidence of Turkic presence in the region dates to the 12th–13th centuries, when Kipchaks invaded Alanian territories in the Western Caucasus. Graves reflecting steppe nomadic burial customs have been found at sites such as Nizhny Arkhyz. Additional waves of migration followed the Mongol incursions. The Karachay-Balkar language is most closely related to Kumyk, and some Kumyks are known to have fled northward from Mongol-occupied regions.[45]

Another hypothesis suggests earlier Turkic influence through the migration of Proto-Bulgars, Sabirs, and Khazars into Alania during the 6th–7th centuries. The ethnonym “Balkar” may derive from these Proto-Bulgars, referred to in Russian sources of the 17th century as “Bolgary” or “Bolchary.[46]

Genetic studies of the Karachay-Balkar population reveal a complex ancestry. A significant haplogroup in the region is G2, found at high frequencies among several Caucasian groups, including 31% of the Karachay. G2 is linked to ancient farming populations from the Colchis region and the Koban culture. The subclades G2a3 and G2a1 are prominent among the Adyghe-Abkhaz peoples and the Ossetians, respectively.[47][48]

Haplogroup R1a,[49] particularly R1a-Z2123,[50] is also notable among the Karachay-Balkars (36% in Karachay and 26% in Balkars),[51] indicating a connection to Scythian, Alan,[52] and Sarmatian populations. This haplogroup is nearly absent in the Ossetians, who are commonly regarded as the direct descendants of the Alans. R1a is also present in other Caucasian groups, including Azerbaijanis and Georgians, suggesting historical ties to the Alans, Scythians, or Khazars.[53][54][47]

These genetic findings highlight the Karachay-Balkars’ multi-layered ethnogenesis, with influences from Turkic, North Caucasian, and Scythian-Alanic populations.[55]

Karachay-Balkar Y-DNA

The Zelenchuk Inscription, discovered in 1888 near the Bolshoy Zelenchuk River in Arkhyz, Russia, is a 10th-century funerary text written in Greek script. It is considered one of the earliest known written samples of the Ossetian language.

Soviet linguist Vasily Abaev interpreted the inscription as evidence of the Ossetian language’s direct descent from Alanic, supporting the view that Ossetians are direct descendants of the Alans.  However, this interpretation has been contested.[56][57][58][59] Critics argue that the inscription can also be read using the Karachay-Balkar language, offering clearer and more coherent results.[60][61] For example, scholars such as K.T. Laipanov[62] and I.M. Miziev[63][64] have suggested that the text, when interpreted through a Turkic lens, yields meaningful phrases, whereas the Ossetian reading results in a list of personal names with limited context.[1][65][66][67]

Further skepticism arises from the fact that the original stone slab has been lost, and subsequent analyses rely on photographs and drawings made in the late 19th century. This absence of the physical artifact complicates definitive linguistic attribution. Additionally, some scholars have criticized Abaev’s methodology, noting that he added letters to the inscription to align it with Ossetian linguistic structures.[68][69] The debate over the inscription’s language reflects broader discussions about the ethnolinguistic heritage of the Alans and the historical narratives of the Ossetian and Karachay-Balkar peoples.

Several significant archaeological discoveries in Karachay-Cherkessia shed light on the region’s diverse cultural heritage, reflecting the influences of Alanic, Caucasian, and Turkic cultures.

One notable find is the Stone Statue of the Turkic Warrior, a medieval menhir created between the 8th and 12th centuries. This three-meter statue, located near the Nizhny Arkhyz settlement, depicts a warrior with distinct Eastern features such as a short chin, straight nose, and artificial skull deformation, characteristic of the ancient Alans and Huns. It stands near the South Zelenchuk Temple.[70]

Stone Statue of the Turkic Warrior
Translation from the sign:Stone Statue Turkic Warrior Monument 8th–12th Century Depicting eastern facial features a short chin, straight nose, and large eye sockets, this statue also exhibits the characteristic artificial cranial deformation typical of the Alans and Huns. An enduring monument to the rich medieval cultural heritage of the region.

The Shuanyn Church, was built at the end of the 10th century. This domed Christian cathedral, located in modern-day Karachay-Cherkessia, belonged to the historical Alanian Diocese. Its architectural design, an inscribed cross, was influenced by the earlier North Zelenchuk Church.

View from the west of the The Shuanyn Church

The North Zelenchuk Church, dating from the 11th century, is located within the Nizhny Arkhyz settlement in the valley of the Bolshoy Zelenchuk River. It is believed to have served as the cathedral of the Alanian Diocese between the 10th and 13th centuries. The church’s dome reaches a height of 21 meters, and its western wall is twice the length of its eastern counterpart. The narthex originally housed a baptistery, and 19th-century travelers noted the faded Byzantine frescoes still visible on its walls.

North Church is dedicated to St. George.

Thus, according to archaeological, linguistic, and genetic evidence, the formation of the Karachay-Balkar people involved:

  1. Indigenous Caucasian highland populations;
  2. The Alans and peoples of medieval Alania;
  3. Turkic-speaking Proto-Bulgars in the 6th–7th centuries;
  4. Kipchaks and other steppe nomads in the 12th–13th centuries.[71]

The Karachay-Balkars thus represent a synthesis of Alanian, Turkic, and native Caucasian elements, with a distinct cultural and linguistic heritage rooted in the highlands of the Central Caucasus.

Maps

[edit]
In Jean Chardin’s 1672 map of the Caucasus, the Karachays are identified as “Caraciole” and “Alani”, located in the mountainous region north of Abkhazia, where they live to this day. The Balkars are also marked as Alani, highlighting their shared Alanic heritage. The map mentions two groups of Alani—one in the mountains, north of the Georgians (Giqui) and Svanets (Suani), and another on the plains, just above them. This distinction suggests both highland and lowland Alanic settlements, offering a rare early recognition of the Karachay-Balkars as heirs of the ancient Alans.
In Pierre Duval’s 1676 map of the Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are marked in their historic homeland and identified as both Alans and Karquirques—an early variation of Karachays. This dual naming highlights their Alanic heritage and enduring presence in the mountainous heart of the North Caucasus.
In Giovanni Giacomo de Rossi’s 1684 map of the Caucasus, the Karachays are identified as Alani and the Balkars as Caracioli. They are positioned north of the Svanets and east of the Circassians, firmly placed within their historical highland homeland. Alongside the Svanetians, they are referred to as “Popoli Liberi del Caucaso”—Free Peoples of the Caucasus—highlighting their independence and deep-rooted presence in the region.
In Robert Morden’s 1687 map of the Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are described as Alanes and Caracioles, with Mount Elbrus (Shadgore) positioned between them. The Alanes are shown on the western side of Elbrus, while the Caracioles are placed on the eastern side. To the south lie the Svans and Mingrelians, and to the west are the Circassians, reflecting the historical distribution of these mountain peoples.
In Jean-Baptiste Nolin’s 1690 map of the Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are collectively identified as “Alani Carcaioli”, a clear reference to their Alanic heritage. They are situated north of the Svanetians, firmly within the mountainous heart of the Caucasus. This unified designation reflects their shared identity and long-standing presence as a distinct people of the region.
In Melchisédech Thévenot’s late 17th-century map of Abkhazia, three nations are identified north of the Abkhazians in the mountainous North Caucasus: the Alani and Carcioli, referring to the Karachay-Balkars, and the Scvani, representing the Svanetians. This classification reflects an early recognition of the distinct highland peoples inhabiting the central Caucasus.
In the 1705 map by Guillaume de L’Isle and John Senex, the Karachay-Balkars are identified as Alans, positioned north of the Svans, precisely where the Karachay-Balkars live today. This reflects their enduring presence in the central Caucasus and their historical connection to the ancient Alans.
In Pieter van der Aa’s 1713 map of the Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are described in the mountain regions as “Alani, Carci di, et Scuani populi sunt liberi qui has regiones colunt”—translated as “The Alans, Karachays, and Svans are free peoples who inhabit these regions.” This description highlights the Karachays (Carci di) and Balkars (Alani) as distinct yet related mountain peoples, recognized for their autonomy and deep roots in the Caucasus alongside the Svans.
The map of the Black Sea by Guillaume Delisle, 1723
In Guillaume De L’Isle’s 1723 map, the term “Alanes” (Alans) refers to the Karachay-Balkar confederation, highlighting their direct link to the ancient Alans. The labels “Petigorie” and “Caracioles ou Circasses Noirs” (Karachays or Black Circassians) denote both the Karachay-Balkars and Nogai Tatars of the region. Meanwhile, the Ossetians are marked separately as “Grand Oßéti” and “Province d’Oßéti,” indicating a clear recognition of the distinct ethnic and territorial identities within the Caucasus.
In Guillaume De L’Isle’s 1724 map, the term “Alanes” (Alans) again refers to the Karachay-Balkar confederation, emphasizing their connection to the ancient Alans. The labels “Caracioles“ identify the Karachay-Balkars within their historical territory. Meanwhile, the Ossetians are distinctly marked as “Osseti,” showcasing the clear differentiation of ethnic and territorial identities in the Caucasus region.
In Johann Matthias Haas’s 1737 map, the Karachay-Balkars are jointly identified as Alans (Alani), positioned in their traditional highland homeland. To the south lie the Georgians and Abkhazians, while to the north and west, the region is bordered by the Circassians. This placement reflects both their geographic reality and their enduring identity as descendants of the ancient Alans.
In the circa 1740 map by Johannes Covens and Cornelis Mortier, the Karachay-Balkars are once again identified as Alans (Alanes), located in their traditional homeland north of the Mingrelians (Georgians) and Circassians.
In Johann Matthias Hase’s 1743 map of the Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are identified as Alans, situated north of Abkhazia and Svanetia. This designation reflects their deep-rooted connection to the ancient Alans and affirms their historical presence in the highlands of the North Caucasus.
Map of Caucasus 1751, by Jean Baptiste Bourguignon d’Anville
In this 1760 map of the Caucasus, drawn by Jean Baptiste Bourguignon d’Anville, we find a remarkable glimpse into the ancestral homelands of the Alans. The map marks the region where the Karachay-Balkars now reside as the land of the Alans, while further east—within the present-day territory of the Balkars—appear the Bascians, identified as Noble Ases or Alans, a testament to their noble Sarmatian lineage. Notably, the Ossetians are indicated as a distinct people, further underscoring the rich tapestry of ethnic identities that have long shaped the Caucasus.
In the 1769 map of Eastern Europe by Tobias Conrad Lotter, the Karachay-Balkars are identified as Alanie, located in the mountainous region of the Caucasus where the Karachays reside today. They are positioned south of the Circassians, near the source of the Kuban River, reflecting their historical homeland and enduring identity as descendants of the ancient Alans.
In Giovanni Antonio Rizzi Zannoni’s 1774 map of the Caucasus, the Karachays are identified as Alans (Alani) and are placed at the headwaters of the Kuban River, marking their historical homeland. Nearby, the Balkars are represented through the names of their noble families and princes, though not described explicitly. In contrast, the Ossetians are distinctly labeled as Kfentfk-Aßetini and Turgavi-Aßetini, indicating a separate recognition of Ossetian groups within the region.
In Paolo Santini’s 1775 map of Georgia, the Karachay-Balkars are identified separately as Alania (Karachays) and Bascian (Balkars), situated north of Svanetia along the middle course of the Kuban River. The Karachays appear on one end of Svanetia, while the Balkars are placed on the opposite side. The Balkars are shown adjacent to Ovseti (Ossetians).
In Rigobert Bonne’s 1789 map, the Karachay-Balkars are referred to as Alans and are shown north of the Svans, in the region where the Karachay-Balkars live today. This map further emphasizes their historical link to the ancient Alans and their longstanding presence in the central Caucasus.
In the 1810 map titled Charte der Laender am Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are depicted as a unified group under the name Bassianen (Bassians). Within this territory, the Karachays are shown living alongside the Chegem, Balkar, and Baksan communities—representing the traditional Balkar societies (общества). Their homeland is centered around Mount Elbrus, which is placed directly under the domain labeled Bassians. The Ossetians (Osseten) are shown adjacent to the Karachay-Balkars, with subgroups like Ironistan and Digor identified beneath them. To the south lie the Imeretians and Mingrelians, to the north the Circassians, to the west the Abazins, and to the east again the Ossetians—placing the Karachay-Balkars at the very heart of the central North Caucasus.
In the 1828 map of the Caucasus related to the Russo-Turkish War by Br. von Ehrenkreutz, the Balkars are referred to as Bassians and are placed north of Mount Elbrus, marking their historical highland territory. A note about the Karachays reads: “Karatschajewer werden Ende 1828 durch Gewalt der Waffen zum Gehorsam gebracht,” which translates to: “The Karachays were brought into submission by force of arms at the end of 1828.” To the east of the Karachay-Balkars are the Ossetians, to the north the Circassians, and to the south the Imeretians and Mingrelians, reflecting the region’s complex ethnic geography during this pivotal period in Caucasian history.
In Thomas Gamaliel Bradford’s 1835 map of the Caucasus, the Karachays are referred to as Basians, while the area where the Balkars live today is incorrectly shown as inhabited by Svans in the North Caucasus. To the north of them are the Abazins, to the west the Circassians, and to the south the Abkhazians, reflecting a somewhat imprecise understanding of the region’s ethnic geography at the time.
In the 1848 map of the Caucasus by Heinrich Berghaus, the Karachay-Balkars are collectively referred to as Turken (Turks), recognizing their Turkic linguistic identity. Within their respective regions, the map provides more specific names: in Karachay, they are listed as Karachay and Baslen (Bassian), while in the Balkar area, the communities are labeled as Balkar, Chegem, and Kamuk. In the lower left corner of the map, Berghaus includes a classification of ethnic groups by language family. Among the Turkic-speaking nations, he identifies three subdivisions for the Karachay-Balkars, naming their language as Bassians (Noble Assian), Karachay, and Alan—a striking blend that reflects both their Turkic tongue and their Alanic-Sarmatian heritage.
In Joseph Meyer’s 1856 map of the Caucasus, the Karachay-Balkars are shown divided by Mount Elbrus: on the western side reside the Karachays, while on the eastern side, the Balkars are identified as Bassian (Noble Ases). This clear distinction reflects both their shared heritage and regional identities, with the term Bassian echoing their ancient Alanic roots as Noble Ases in the highlands of the central Caucasus.

History

[edit]

Background

[edit]

In the late 1920s, the Soviet government, led by Joseph Stalin, initiated a program of forced collectivization as part of its First Five-Year Plan. The aim was to consolidate small farms into collective farms (kolkhozes) to increase agricultural productivity, provide food for industrial workers, and extend state control over rural areas. However, this policy was met with fierce resistance in many parts of the Soviet Union, especially in regions with a strong tradition of individual farming, such as the Karachay Autonomous Oblast.

The Karachay people, an ethnic group native to the region, were primarily involved in agriculture, and many of them were either kulaks (wealthier farmers) or middle peasants. Stalin’s collectivization policies alienated these groups, as they were forced to surrender land and livestock, face grain requisitions, and deal with punitive measures for not meeting quotas. This led to the escalation of unrest, culminating in the uprising of 1930.

Causes of the Uprising

[edit]

Several key factors contributed to the outbreak of the Karachay Uprising:

1. Collectivization and Grain Requisitioning: The forced requisitioning of grain and livestock by Soviet authorities for export or state consumption led to widespread shortages and suffering. The Karachay people, like many other rural populations, resented the imposition of these policies, which they perceived as exploitation.

2. Deportations and Repressions: Soviet authorities targeted kulaks as “class enemies,” subjecting them to arrest, deportation, and execution. Many Karachay peasants who were branded as kulaks were persecuted, leading to increased resentment toward Soviet rule.

3. Cultural and Religious Suppression: In addition to economic policies, the Soviet government also sought to suppress local customs and religion. The Karachay, like many other ethnic groups, had a strong connection to their traditions and Islamic faith. The Soviet authorities’ efforts to impose secularism and restrict religious practices contributed to the growing discontent.

4. Local Leadership and Organization: The uprising was galvanized by local leaders, many of whom were former kulaks or middle peasants who had experienced repression under the Soviet regime. These leaders rallied the local population to resist collectivization and to fight against Soviet authority.

Timeline of the Uprising

[edit]

The Karachay Uprising began in March 1930 and lasted until April 1930, with key events unfolding throughout this period:

• March 1930: The uprising began when peasants, led by both kulak and middle peasant leaders, formed armed groups to resist collectivization. These groups initially targeted Soviet agricultural officials, land requisitioners, and Red Army units. The rebellion spread quickly across the region, with the insurgents seizing control of key towns, including Mikoyan-Shahar, Kislovodsk, and Batalpashinsk.

• March-April 1930: The Soviet government responded by mobilizing a combination of Red Army units and local militia forces to crush the revolt. The authorities launched a series of punitive expeditions aimed at recapturing the seized towns and suppressing rebel activity. The insurgents used guerrilla tactics and sought to rally more peasants to their cause.

• April 1930: By the end of April, the uprising had been decisively crushed by Soviet forces. The Red Army encircled the rebel groups and employed brutal tactics to suppress them. Many of the leaders of the uprising were arrested or executed, and several hundred rebels were killed in the fighting.

Key Leaders of the Uprising

[edit]

The Karachay Uprising had a number of prominent leaders, both among the rebels and the Soviet forces:

Rebel Leaders:

• Ismail Berdiyev: A former kulak and one of the central figures in the uprising. Berdiyev was a key military leader who played a significant role in organizing the resistance against Soviet forces. He was eventually captured and executed after the defeat of the rebellion.

• Abulkerim Hasanov: A leader of the uprising, Hasanov was involved in the armed resistance against the Soviet forces and was one of the prominent figures in the local peasant movement. He led several attacks against Soviet forces before being captured.

• Kady Bayramukov: Another key leader of the revolt, Bayramukov was involved in rallying the peasants and organizing resistance against collectivization efforts. His role was instrumental in the initial successes of the uprising before Soviet forces gained the upper hand.

• Islam Baychorov: Baychorov played a key role in organizing armed resistance in the northern parts of Karachay. He was known for his strategic acumen and leadership on the battlefield.

• Isse Mamchuev: A former soldier who became one of the leaders of the resistance, Mamchuev led several skirmishes with Soviet forces and helped to coordinate guerrilla attacks in the region.

• Askerbiy Semenov: Semenov was an influential leader among the insurgents who helped coordinate local efforts and led various engagements against the Soviet authorities during the uprising.

Soviet Leaders:

• Sergey Kirov: Kirov, a prominent Soviet leader and ally of Stalin, was involved in the broader context of Soviet policies during this time. Although Kirov did not directly participate in the suppression of the Karachay Uprising, his political influence and role as the head of the Soviet Union’s Party organization made him a key figure in enforcing Stalinist policies across the Soviet territories, including the repression of uprisings and dissent.

• Semyon Budyonny: As a prominent Red Army commander, Budyonny was involved in suppressing the uprising. He oversaw the deployment of Red Army troops to the region and coordinated the military response to the rebellion.

• Nikolai Yezhov: As a high-ranking official in the Soviet security apparatus, Yezhov was responsible for implementing repressive measures against the peasantry in the North Caucasus, including during the suppression of the Karachay Uprising.

Strength and Casualties

[edit]

Rebel Strength:

• Approximately 5,000 peasants participated in the uprising, with around 2,000 armed rebels actively engaged in the fighting.

• The rebels were primarily kulaks (220), followed by middle peasants (1,059), and poor peasants (517). The last group included some individuals who had previously participated in other uprisings in the region.

Soviet Forces:

• The Soviet response was robust, with Red Army units and local Soviet militias mobilized to suppress the rebellion. The exact size of the Soviet forces is unclear, but they were sufficient to overwhelm the rebels through superior numbers, organization, and firepower.

Casualties:

• Rebel Casualties: Following an uprising in Karachay in 1930, Soviet authorities launched a brutal campaign of mass arrests and executions. Several hundred rebels were killed in combat during the initial suppression, and many more were captured. In the sweeping crackdown that followed, an estimated 3,000 people labeled as “rebels” by the Soviet regime were executed. Soviet reprisals continued with further mass executions and deportations, ultimately claiming the lives of hundreds, if not thousands, of those accused of insurgency.

• Soviet Casualties: The Soviet forces sustained approximately 200 casualties, including both killed and wounded. However, the Soviet military’s superior firepower and numbers ensured the defeat of the uprising with relatively limited losses.

Aftermath

[edit]

The Karachay Uprising was ruthlessly suppressed by Soviet forces, and the region suffered harsh reprisals in the wake of the rebellion. Key figures among the insurgents were arrested, and many were executed. In the years following the uprising, the Karachay people were subjected to severe repression, with many deported to remote regions of the Soviet Union.

The Soviet government also accelerated the process of collectivization in the region, forcibly consolidating small farms into large collective farms (kolkhozes). The Karachay population was subjected to intense surveillance, and many traditional practices and cultural expressions were suppressed in favor of state-sponsored collectivism.

In the aftermath of the rebellion, the Karachay Autonomous Oblast was placed under direct Soviet control, and a heavy-handed policy of repression continued throughout the 1930s. The Karachay people, alongside other North Caucasian ethnic groups, would face further persecution during Stalin’s purges, culminating in the deportation of the entire Karachay population in 1943 under accusations of collaboration with the Nazis.

Legacy

[edit]

The Karachay Uprising serves as an important example of the widespread resistance to Stalin’s collectivization policies, which led to countless uprisings across the Soviet Union. It highlights the severe social and economic upheaval that accompanied the forced consolidation of agriculture, and the brutal measures the Soviet state used to suppress dissent. The uprising also underscores the ethnic and cultural dimensions of Soviet repression, particularly in the North Caucasus, where traditional societies were disrupted by Stalinist policies.

The legacy of the Karachay Uprising is one of both resistance and tragedy. The rebellion remains a powerful symbol of peasant resistance to authoritarian rule and the repression faced by ethnic minorities under Stalin’s regime. It continues to be a subject of historical interest and a key chapter in the history of Soviet repression and its impact on the peoples of the Soviet Union.

Bibliography

[edit]

References

[edit]
  • William of Rubruck. *Relation des voyages en Tartarie*. 1255. Link
  • Abulfeda. *Taqwim al-Buldan*. 14th century. Link
  • Herberstein, S. *Moscoviter Wunderbare Historien*. 1549. Link
  • English map of the Caucasus, 1769. Link
  • Nicolaes Witsen. *Noord en Oost Tartarye*. 1692. Link

See Also

[edit]

Refrences

[edit]
  1. ^ a b "И.Мизиев. Аланы и асы - предки балкарцев и карачаевцев". passion-don.org. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  2. ^ a b Richmond, Walter (2008-06-11). The Northwest Caucasus: Past, Present, Future. Routledge. ISBN 978-1-134-00249-8.
  3. ^ Zharnikova, Svetlana (2025-02-12). Cultural traditions and the origin of the Indo-Europeans. Litres. ISBN 978-5-04-723165-5.
  4. ^ Johanson, L., & Csató, É. Á. (1998). ''The Turkic Languages.'' London & New York, p. 68; Scharlipp, W.-E. (2011). ''Die frühen Türken in Zentralasien.'' Darmstadt, pp. 5–29.
  5. ^ "I". kcr.narod.ru. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  6. ^ Byzantine Chronicle 1962, No. 21. Leningrad/Moscow: Academy of Sciences of the USSR. its ridge extending eastward, forms part of the main Caucasus mountain chain, and lies adjacent to the high mountain Naziemta, which separates the northern and eastern lands of the Svanetians from the Alans or Karachays, Kabardians, and Ossetians.
  7. ^ a b "'der allerneueste staat von casan, astracan, georgien, und vieler andern dem czaren, sultan und schach zinsbaren und unterthanen tartarn, landschaften und provinzien : samt einer kurzen nachricht von der caspischen see, dem daria-strom, ingleichen von dem persischen hof, und dessen allerneuesten staats- und kriegs-verfassung ; zur erläuterung der russisch- und persischen kriegs-operationen entworfen, und mit dienlichen kupfern ausgezieret' - Digitalisat | MDZ". www.digitale-sammlungen.de. Retrieved 2025-04-26. To the Circassians are also attributed the Alans or the inhabitants of the Caucasus, the mountaineers. And equally Caraciol or Caracherkes (Karachay-Balkars), the latter refers to the northern Circassians and are called Turks Caracherkes (black Circassians).
  8. ^ Materials of the Scientific Session on the Problem of the Origin of the Balkar and Karachay Peoples (PDF). Nalchik. 1960. pp. 131–133.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  9. ^ a b Shumkin, A. V. (2019). The Turks of the Central Caucasus in the 16th–18th Centuries (Problems of Ethnic History). Chelyabinsk: ChGIK. (Institute of Russian History, Russian Academy of Sciences)
  10. ^ "La vita, et sito de Zychi, chiamati Ciarcassi, Historia notabile - Wikisource". it.wikisource.org (in Italian). Retrieved 2025-04-26. They bordered on the land of the Scythians, that is, the Tartars.
  11. ^ Guignes, Joseph de (1756). Histoire générale des Huns, des Turcs, des Mongols et des autres Tartares occidentaux, avant et depuis Jésus-Christ jusqu'à présent (in French). The Chinese considered the Alans to be Huns. In fact, these peoples lived under tents that they transported—just like the Huns—to the places they deemed most suitable for feeding their herds." "The Alans were, therefore, a nomadic people, like other Tartars." "The Alans formerly lived much further north, above the sources of the Jaik (Ural River), and roughly in the region of Ufa and Solamskoi. All these territories, including even Tobolsk, the capital of Siberia, were then under the domination of the Tanjou Tchi-tchi. The Alans were so named from the word Alin, which means 'mountain', because they lived in the mountains. They later moved further south, into the plains situated north of Circassia and Derbend. {{cite book}}: line feed character in |quote= at position 193 (help)
  12. ^ "Эльбрусоид :: Библиотека :: Аланы в древних и средневековых письменных источниках". www.elbrusoid.org. Retrieved 2025-04-13.
  13. ^ Karachays. Balkars, 2014
  14. ^ Jafar, Ismailzade Saida (2024-05-30). KIPCHAKS IN THE CAUCASUS. International Science Group. ISBN 979-8-89443-789-7.
  15. ^ Spiegel, Fr (Friedrich) (1871–78). Erânische alterthumskunde. Getty Research Institute. Leipzig, W. Engelmann.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: date format (link)
  16. ^ a b Tavkul, Ufuk (2024-01-01). "The Karachay Autonomous Region in The Stalin Era". Modern Türklük Araştırmaları Dergisi.
  17. ^ Baker, Karen (2013-08-30). The Balkars of Southern Russia and Their Deportation (1944-57). William Carey Publishing. ISBN 978-1-64508-114-2.
  18. ^ Karny, Yo'av (2000). Highlanders: A Journey to the Caucasus in Quest of Memory. Farrar, Straus and Giroux. ISBN 978-0-374-22602-2.
  19. ^ Basik, Sergei (2022-11-01). Encountering Toponymic Geopolitics: Place Names as a Political Instrument in the Post-Soviet States. Taylor & Francis. ISBN 978-1-000-77811-3.
  20. ^ a b c Endangered Languages of the Caucasus and Beyond. BRILL. 2016-11-01. ISBN 978-90-04-32869-3.
  21. ^ "Древние сведения о балкарцах и карачаевцах". kmvline.ru. Retrieved 2025-05-09.
  22. ^ Carpin, Jean du Plan (1634). Relation des voyages en Tartarie (in French). chez Michel Soly. Once you leave the land of Gazaria, with the sea to the south and great deserts to the north stretching sometimes more than twenty days' journey there are many forests there without mountains or stones. The grass is very good for pastures. It was there that the Cumans lived and grazed their herds; they are called 'Capchat,'(Kipchak) and the Germans call them 'Valans,' and their land 'Valania.' Isidore calls it 'Alania,' stretching from the Tanais (Don River) to the Maeotian Marshes (Sea of Azov) and to the Danube. And all that land in length extends from the Danube to the Tanais.
  23. ^ Relation des voyages en Tartarie, William of Rubruck, (1253)
  24. ^ Abul Fida; Abdul Muhammad Ayati. Taqveetumul Buldan, early 14th century. Intisharat E Buniad Farhang, Iran. Ibn-Sayd continues as follows: To the east of the Abkhazians, on the shores of the sea, is the city of the Alans (Medynet-Allanyé). This city is so named because a people of Alan descent inhabit it; the Alans (Alallans) are Turks who have embraced Christianity. The longitude of this city is sixty-nine degrees and its latitude forty-six. The Alans are established in great numbers in this region, as well as beyond the Gates of the Gates (towards the west). Nearby is a people of Turkic origin called the Asse (Alass); this people shares the same ancestry and the same religion as the Alans.
  25. ^ Muqaddimat Ibn Khaldūn li-Kitāb al-ʻibar wa-dīwān al-mubtadaʼ wa-al-Khabar fī ayyām al-ʻArab wa-al-ʻAjam wa-al-Barbar, wa-man ʻāṣarahum min dhawī al-sulṭān al-akbar (in Arabic). McGill University Library. al-Maṭabaʻah al-Bahīyah al-Miṣrīyah. 1377. The Turkic tribes include the Bulgars, Khazars, Kipchaks, and among these Turkic tribes are the Yamuks and the Alans, who are also called the Ases.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: others (link)
  26. ^ نور, مكتبة. "download book spread the earth in length and width ibn sa id al maghribi pdf". www.noor-book.com. Retrieved 2025-04-26. To the east of it, on the sea, lies the city of Alaniyya. It is inhabited by people from the Al-'Alan (Alans) nation, who are Christianized Turks. Its coordinates are 69 degrees longitude and 46 degrees latitude. The Al-'Alan are a numerous people living in that region and behind Bab al-Abwab. Nearby lives a Turkic people called al-As' (Assians), who are similar to them in their customs and faith.
  27. ^ Vitae Caesarum quarum scriptores hi C. Suetonius Tranquillus ... Ammianus Marcellinus longe alius quàm antehac unquam. Annotationes D. Erasmi Rot. & Baptistae Egnatij in vitas Caess. Accesserunt in hac editione Velleij Paterculi libri II. ab innumeris denuo vendicati erroribus, additio indice copiosissimo (in Latin). per Hieronymum Frobenium et Nic. Episcopium. 1546. Meanwhile, the Huns or Alans, who are Tartars, nomadic Scythians, came from the region beyond the Tanais (Don River). After crossing the Ister (Danube), they wandered through Pannonia, Epirus, and Thessaly.
  28. ^ Michaelis Antonii Baudrand Parisini Geographia ordine litterarum disposita. Tomus primus secundus. Michael Antoine Baudrand. 1682. The Scythians, a very famous people according to Strabo and Pliny, extended through all of Asia, and their territory stretched far across the northern part of Asia, divided into many peoples. Among these, the principal ones were the Hyperborean Scythians, living further to the north, followed by the Orgasi, Sace, and Alani-Scythians. The nations of the Scythians are enumerated by Pliny and Prolemo, who provide further details. Their region is now known as Tartaria, and the people themselves are called Tartars or Tatars by various nations: the French call them Tartares, the Italians Tartari, the Spanish Tártaros, the Germans Tartaren, the English Tartars, and the Poles Tatarzyn.
  29. ^ Peyssonnel, Claude Charles de; Peyssonnel (Charles), M. de (1765). Observations historiques et géographiques: sur les peuples barbares qui ont habité les bords du Danube & du Pont-Euxin (in French). N.M. Tilliard. "…and they extended their raids as far as the Tanais (Don River); but they were poorly received by the inhabitants of that region, whose principal peoples were the Alans and the Huns, who were part of the Scythians and the Eastern Sarmatians. The Alans, a Tartar people, lived in the triangular region of Asiatic Sarmatia, formed by the Tanais (Don), the Volga, and the Caucasus Mountains. Procopius more precisely identifies their…" "The Huns, who are placed around the area of the Maeotian Marshes (Sea of Azov), must have been situated between the Tanais (Don) and the Borysthenes (Dnieper), in the region that today is called Muscovite Ukraine; but they were not known under the name of Huns at that time." "The Scythians, whom I have said to be the ancestors of the Bulgars, were situated above the Alans and near the Volga. {{cite book}}: line feed character in |quote= at position 243 (help)
  30. ^ Peyssonnel, Claude Charles de; Peyssonnel (Charles), M. de (1765). Observations historiques et géographiques: sur les peuples barbares qui ont habité les bords du Danube & du Pont-Euxin (in French). N.M. Tilliard. The Alans, a Tartar people, lived in the triangle of Asiatic Sarmatia, formed by the Tanais (Don River), the Volga, and the Caucasus Mountains. Procopius more precisely determined their position from this mountain range to the Caspian Gates, thus indicating the regions that we today call Circassia, Kabarda, and Dagestan{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: date and year (link)
  31. ^ "Image 237 of The native races of the Russian empire. 1854". Library of Congress, Washington, D.C. 20540 USA. Retrieved 2025-04-26. That all the Turks of Europe—Scythian, Alan, Hun, Avar, Chazar, Uz, Petsheneg, and Cumanian— came from Asia, was known.
  32. ^ Chardin, Jean (1686). Journal du voyage du chevalier Chardin en Perse et aux Indes Orientales par la Mer Noire et par la Colchide (in French). Chez M. Pitt. The peoples of Mount Caucasus with whom it borders are the Georgians and the Turks to the south, and to the north the Ossi (Assians) and the Caracioles (Karachays), whom the Turks call Caracherkes (Black Circassians), that is to say, Black Circassians for the reasons I have explained. It is these Caracioles or Black Circassians whom the Europeans called Huns, who carried out all those devastations in Italy and in Gaul spoken of by the historians, among others Cedrenus. The language they speak is mixed with Turkish.
  33. ^ Miechowa), Maciej (z (1518). Tractatus de duabus Sarmatiis Asiana et Europiana et de contentis in eis (in Latin). Grimm u. Wirsung. From Chapter Three: On Alania — Dandalis and the Suci. The Alani were a people in the region of Alania, part of Sarmatia Europaea, neighboring and adjoining the river Zanai (likely the Don or a related river). The land is flat, without mountains, with few settlements and low hills; it was well-suited to colonies and habitation. But they were attacked and scattered by invaders, consumed and extinguished in foreign provinces. The plains of Alania stretch wide: now abandoned and desolate, deprived of both Alani and other inhabitants. Meanwhile, the Asaci pass through the territory, seeking—as is their custom—some place or people to conquer.
  34. ^ "Эльбрусоид :: Библиотека :: Сколько знаменитых карачаев (карчей) было / Ненча байракълы къарачай (къарча) болгъанды". www.elbrusoid.org. Retrieved 2025-04-13.
  35. ^ "Карачаево-Черкесия. Замковый камень Къарчи". Информационно аналитическое интеллектуальное электронное СМИ: туриз (in Russian). 2012-04-16. Retrieved 2025-04-13.
  36. ^ Samir, Khotko. Карачай - страна на вершине Кавказа.
  37. ^ "История алан КЧР - КБР. Юг России -малоизвестное.: Карачайбалкары (аланы и карачеркесы) на карте 17 века". История алан КЧР - КБР. Юг России -малоизвестное. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  38. ^ Лобжанидзе, Александр; Заяц, Дмитрий (2015-01-20). Этнокультурные регионы мира (in Russian). Litres. ISBN 978-5-457-69248-0.
  39. ^ Shvetsov, V. (1856). “Essay on the Caucasian Highland Tribes with Their Rites and Customs in Civil, Military, and Domestic Life.”
  40. ^ "Эльбрусоид :: Библиотека :: О происхождении балкарцев и карачаевцев". www.elbrusoid.org. Retrieved 2025-04-13.
  41. ^ "Kokiev, G. A. (1941). On the question of the origin and time of settlement of the Balkars and Karachays in their present territory. // Socialist Kabardino-Balkaria". Ilmu.su (in Russian). 2016-03-07. Retrieved 2025-04-13.
  42. ^ Кокиев, Георгий (2005). История Кабардино-Балкарии в трудах Г.А. Кокиева: сборник статей и документов (in Russian). Республиканский полиграфкомбинат им. Революции 1905 г. ISBN 978-5-88195-671-4.
  43. ^ See Maps
  44. ^ Nedjalkov, Vladimir P. (2007-11-06). Reciprocal Constructions. John Benjamins Publishing. ISBN 978-90-272-9171-4.
  45. ^ Johanson, Lars; Johanson, Éva Ágnes Csató (2015-04-29). "The Turkic Languages": 68–69. doi:10.4324/9780203066102. {{cite journal}}: Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
  46. ^ "Kusnezow, W. A. (n.d.). Outline of Alanic History. Section 9.1".
  47. ^ a b "Коллизия популяционной генетики и ДНК-генеалогии (часть 3)". pereformat.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  48. ^ Genogeography of Turkic-speaking Peoples of the Caucasus: An Analysis of Y-Chromosome Variability
  49. ^ Underhill, Peter A.; Poznik, G. David; Rootsi, Siiri; Järve, Mari; Lin, Alice A.; Wang, Jianbin; Passarelli, Ben; Kanbar, Jad; Myres, Natalie M.; King, Roy J.; Di Cristofaro, Julie; Sahakyan, Hovhannes; Behar, Doron M.; Kushniarevich, Alena; Šarac, Jelena (2015-01). "The phylogenetic and geographic structure of Y-chromosome haplogroup R1a". European Journal of Human Genetics. 23 (1): 124–131. doi:10.1038/ejhg.2014.50. ISSN 1476-5438. {{cite journal}}: Check date values in: |date= (help)
  50. ^ "Хазары: что показал ДНК-анализ останков?". KM.RU Новости - новости дня, новости России, последние новости и комментарии (in Russian). 2016. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  51. ^ Battaglia, Vincenza; Fornarino, Simona; Al-Zahery, Nadia; Olivieri, Anna; Pala, Maria; Myres, Natalie M.; King, Roy J.; Rootsi, Siiri; Marjanovic, Damir; Primorac, Dragan; Hadziselimovic, Rifat; Vidovic, Stojko; Drobnic, Katia; Durmishi, Naser; Torroni, Antonio. "Y-chromosomal evidence of the cultural diffusion of agriculture in Southeast Europe". European journal of human genetics: EJHG. 17 (6): 820–830. doi:10.1038/ejhg.2008.249. ISSN 1476-5438. PMC 2947100. PMID 19107149.
  52. ^ "Афанасьев Г.Е., Коробов Д.С., 2018. Северокавказские аланы по данным палеогенетики". Archived from the original on 2023-10-05. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  53. ^ "Коллизия популяционной генетики и ДНК-генеалогии (часть 1)". pereformat.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  54. ^ "Коллизия популяционной генетики и ДНК-генеалогии (часть 2)". pereformat.ru (in Russian). Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  55. ^ Results of Y-DNA investigations broken down to individual families by: A.-Ch. A. Katschijew, T.B. Usdenow, Ch. B. Chasanow: Structures of Karachay family origin and their correlation with the results of Y-chromosomal DNA investigations. Cherkessk, Moscow, Karachayevsk 2016. (Russian)
  56. ^ Дроздов, Юрий Николаевич (2011). Тюркскоязычный период европейской истории (in Russian). DrozdovYuN. ISBN 978-5-904729-20-2.
  57. ^ Дзиковицкий, Александр (2022-05-15). Этнокультурная история казаков. Часть III. Славянская надстройка. Книга 4 (in Russian). Litres. ISBN 978-5-04-022882-9.
  58. ^ Un-Making Sense of Alleged Abkhaz-Adyghean Inscriptions on Ancient Greek Pottery
  59. ^ T.A. Murtazov, Zelenchuk Inscription: Translation of the Inscription in Abkhaz-Abaza Language, 2013
  60. ^ Дзиковицкий, Александр (2022-05-15). Казаки. Осознание себя. Этническое возрождение. Казачьи основы (in Russian). Litres. ISBN 978-5-04-157503-8.
  61. ^ М.З, Закиев (2011-07-04). Глубокие этнические корни тюркских народов (in Russian). Астана, "Тюркская Академия". ISBN 978-601-7340-01-8.
  62. ^ K.T. Laipanov “Ethnogenetic Connections of the Karachay-Balkars with Other Peoples”
  63. ^ Мусаевич, Мизиев, Исмаил (2010-03-07). История Балкарии и Карачая в трудах Исмаила Мизиева: В 3 т. (in Russian). Нальчик: Издательство М. и В. Котляровых. ISBN 978-5-93680-337-6.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  64. ^ Steps to the Origins of the Ethnic History of the Central Caucasus by I.M. Miziev, published in 1986
  65. ^ РедакцияTuranToday.com. "Аланы: кто они?". TuranToday. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  66. ^ Закиев, М. З. (2003). Происхождение тюрков и татар (in Russian). Инсан. ISBN 978-5-85840-317-3.
  67. ^ Тебуев, Рамазан Сагитович; Хатуев, Рашид Тохтарович (2002). Очерки истории карачаево-балкарцев (in Russian). Илекса. ISBN 978-5-93078-107-6.
  68. ^ "«Зеленчукская надпись» и ее сомнительная трактовка". cherkesk.bezformata.com. Retrieved 2025-04-25.
  69. ^ Khabichev, Magomed Akhii︠a︡vich (1971). Карачаево-балкарское именное словообразование: (Опыт сравнит.-ист. изучения) (in Russian). Ставроп. кн. изд-во, Карачаево-Черкес. отд-ние.
  70. ^ "Yandex". sso.passport.yandex.ru. Retrieved 2025-04-26.
  71. ^ Alekseeva, E. P. (2021). Karachay and Balkars: Ancient Peoples of the Caucasus. Moscow & Kislovodsk. PDF
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:DatoShp/sandbox&oldid=1289628104"