Jump to content

User:Chess/sandbox

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
  • Comment: See
Created with templates {{ORGCRIT assess table}} and {{ORGCRIT assess}}
This table may not be a final or consensus view; it may summarize developing consensus, or reflect assessments of a single editor.
Source Independent? Reliable? Significant coverage? Secondary? Overall value toward ORGCRIT
No Website of the company itself – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes The company discusses itself in detail. No The company is a primary source on itself.
No A podcast/interview co-hosted by the 3Dsurvey host is not independent – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes No Interviews are a primary source.
No Sponsored by the company – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes Yes
No Sponsored by the company – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes Yes
No Company website – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes No
No Written by 3Dsurvey – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF. No Doesn't cover the company. Yes
No Company website – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF. Yes No
No It appears that GIM case studies are written by the company they are about.[1] – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF. Yes No
No Written by 3Dsurvey – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF. No Yes
No Sponsored by the company – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes Yes
Yes No This doesn't appear at first glance to meet Wikipedia's standards for reliable sources. Ideally, news sites should have a clear editorial policy. This article is also not credited to a particular writer, which is a negative for its reliability. I'm open to being convinced otherwise, though. Yes Yes
No Credited to 3Dsurvey and is an interview – Companies can be reliable on themselves per WP:ABOUTSELF. Yes No
No Credited to 3Dsurvey and is an interview – Companies can be reliable on themselves per WP:ABOUTSELF. Yes No
No Sponsored by the company – A company can be reliable on itself per WP:ABOUTSELF Yes Yes
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Chess/sandbox&oldid=1282449475"