Jump to content

Battle of Sidi Brahim: Difference between revisions

Coordinates: 35°15′38″N 0°34′03″W / 35.2606°N 0.5675°W / 35.2606; -0.5675
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Content deleted Content added
Battle: detail with Source on Algerian casualties
Tag: Reverted
Restored revision 1271361238 by M.Bitton (talk): Source misrepresentation + unreliable source (a blog): see the talk page
Tags: Twinkle Undo Reverted
Line 12: Line 12:
| commander1 = [[Lucien de Montagnac]]{{KIA}} <br /> Captain Dutertre{{KIA}} <br/> Captain de Géreaux{{KIA}}
| commander1 = [[Lucien de Montagnac]]{{KIA}} <br /> Captain Dutertre{{KIA}} <br/> Captain de Géreaux{{KIA}}
| commander2 = [[Emir Abdelkader]]
| commander2 = [[Emir Abdelkader]]
| strength1 = {{circa}} 500{{sfn|Holstein|2019|p=16}}
| strength1 = 500{{sfn|Holstein|2019|p=16}}
| strength2 = 1,000 to 1,200{{sfn|Al Arabi|1986|p=23}}
| strength2 = 1,000 to 1,200{{sfn|Al Arabi|1986|p=23}}
| casualties1 = 489{{sfn|Holstein|2019|p=16}}
| casualties1 = {{circa}} 360 dead, 141 captured <ref>{{cite web |title=Noms des prisonniers dans la Deïra d'Abd el Kader Sidi-Brahim et Sidi-Moussa (1845-1846) |url=https://sidibrahim.canalblog.com/archives/2014/02/11/29188308.html |access-date=24 January 2025}}</ref>
| casualties2 = Unknown
| casualties2 = 210 killed <ref>{{cite news |title=Tlemcen/bataille de Sidi Brahim: occasion pour mettre en exergue la place de l’Emir Abdelkader |url=https://www.aps.dz/regions/127736-tlemcen-bataille-de-sidi-brahim-occasion-pour-mettre-en-exergue-la-place-de-l-emir-abdelkader |access-date=24 January 2025 |agency=Algerie Presse Service |date=21 September 2021}}</ref>
}}
}}
{{Campaignbox French conquest of Algeria}}
{{Campaignbox French conquest of Algeria}}
The '''Battle of Sidi Brahim''', 23 to 25 September 1845, took place during the [[French conquest of Algeria]], near [[Souahlia]] in [[Tlemcen Province]]. Between 1,000 to 1,200 Algerian irregulars under [[Emir Abdelkader]] ambushed a French detachment of around 500 led by Lieutenant-Colonel [[Lucien de Montagnac]]. Most of the latter were killed or captured in the initial fighting, and only eleven were reported to have ultimately survived the encounter.
The '''Battle of Sidi Brahim''', 23 to 25 September 1845, took place during the [[French conquest of Algeria]], near [[Souahlia]] in [[Tlemcen Province]]. Between 1,000 to 1,200 Algerian irregulars under [[Emir Abdelkader]] ambushed a French detachment of 500 led by Lieutenant-Colonel [[Lucien de Montagnac]]. Most of the latter were killed in the initial fighting, and only eleven were reported to have ultimately survived the encounter.


Despite their defeat, the French used the battle as a symbol of the price paid to acquire [[French Algeria]], and in 1898, a monument to the "martyrs of Sidi-Brahim" was installed in [[Oran]]. After [[Algerian War|Algerian independence]] in 1962, the monument was transformed into one commemorating Emir Abdelkader, and anti-colonial resistance in general.
Despite their defeat, the French used the battle as a symbol of the price paid to acquire [[French Algeria]], and in 1898, a monument to the "martyrs of Sidi-Brahim" was installed in [[Oran]]. After [[Algerian War|Algerian independence]] in 1962, the monument was transformed into one commemorating Emir Abdelkader, and anti-colonial resistance in general.
Line 24: Line 24:
==Background==
==Background==


{{Location map many|Algeria|caption=French Algeria circa 1845|width=200|float=left
|relief = yes
|label1 = Ghazaouet |lat1_deg = 35.1 |lon1_deg = -1.85 |pos1=left
|label2 = Oran |lat2_deg = 35.696944|lon2_deg = -0.633 |pos2=right
|label3 = Algiers |lat3_deg = 36.7325 |lon3_deg = 3.087222|pos3= right
}}
The [[French conquest of Algeria]] began with the capture of [[Invasion of Algiers (1830)|Algiers]] in 1830, and over the next decade expanded along the coast. In 1840, three French provinces were created, [[Constantine (département)|Constantine]] in the east, [[Alger (département)|Alger]] in the centre, and [[Oran (department)|Oran]] in the west. However, intense guerrilla fighting continued in the interior, headed in western Algeria by [[Emir Abdelkader]]. Although isolated French detachments were still vulnerable to surprise attacks, by 1845 a ruthless [[scorched earth]] policy employing small numbers of fast moving troops had eliminated most remaining resistance.{{sfn|Horne|1977|pp=29-30}}
The [[French conquest of Algeria]] began with the capture of [[Invasion of Algiers (1830)|Algiers]] in 1830, and over the next decade expanded along the coast. In 1840, three French provinces were created, [[Constantine (département)|Constantine]] in the east, [[Alger (département)|Alger]] in the centre, and [[Oran (department)|Oran]] in the west. However, intense guerrilla fighting continued in the interior, headed in western Algeria by [[Emir Abdelkader]]. Although isolated French detachments were still vulnerable to surprise attacks, by 1845 a ruthless [[scorched earth]] policy employing small numbers of fast moving troops had eliminated most remaining resistance.{{sfn|Horne|1977|pp=29-30}}


In September 1845, Lieutenant-Colonel [[Lucien de Montagnac]], commander of the garrison at [[Ghazaouet]], was ordered to arrest Abdelkader, who was reported to be near [[Souahlia]], twenty kilometres to the south. Expecting to receive support from one of the local tribes, he took six companies of [[light infantry]] and a squadron of [[hussars]], totalling between 450 to 500 men, and left Ghazaouet on the night of 21 September. Allegedly unpopular with his troops, Montagnac was a hard-bitten colonial veteran, whose "own writings boast of several war crimes".{{sfn|Manceron|2003|p=168}}
In September 1845, Lieutenant-Colonel [[Lucien de Montagnac]], commander of the garrison at [[Ghazaouet]], was ordered to arrest Abdelkader, who was reported to be near [[Souahlia]], twenty kilometres to the south. Taking six companies of [[light infantry]] and a squadron of [[hussars]], totalling between 450 to 500 men, he left Ghazaouet on the night of 21 September. Allegedly unpopular with his troops, Montagnac was a hard-bitten colonial veteran, whose "own writings boast of several war crimes".{{sfn|Manceron|2003|p=168}}


==Battle==
==Battle==
{{Unreferenced section|date=December 2024}}
{{Unreferenced section|date=December 2024}}
On the evening of 22 September, the French made camp near Souahlia, and just after 9:00 am on 23 September, Montagnac spotted a small force of Algerian cavalry in the distance. Leaving only two companies to guard the baggage, he led the rest of his detachment to intercept them. This proved to be a well-planned trap, and within minutes, the entire force was killed or captured, including Montagnac. The French later estimated their opponents numbered over 3,000,{{sfn|Garnier|2004|p=37}} but Algerian sources suggest no more than 1,000 to 1,200.{{sfn|Al Arabi|1986|p=23}}
On the evening of 22 September, the French made camp near Souahlia, and just after dawn on 23 September, Montagnac spotted a small force of Algerian cavalry in the distance. Leaving only two companies to guard the baggage, he led the rest of his detachment to intercept them. This proved to be a well-planned trap, and within minutes, the entire force was killed, including Montagnac. The French later estimated their opponents numbered over 3,000,{{sfn|Garnier|2004|p=37}} but Algerian sources suggest no more than 1,000 to 1,200.{{sfn|Al Arabi|1986|p=23}}


One of the two companies in reserve tried to rescue their comrades but was also overwhelmed, leaving 79 men from the 8th Carabinier Company under Captain Géreaux, along with six hussars. Retreating into a nearby monument to a local [[Marabout]], they were surrounded but refused to surrender. One of the French prisoners, [[adjutant]] Captain Dutertre, was then ordered to demand they comply, but instead urged them to fight to the death, and was promptly executed.
One of the two companies in reserve tried to rescue their comrades but was also overwhelmed, leaving 79 men from the 8th Carabinier Company under Captain Géreaux, along with six hussars. Retreating into a nearby monument to a local [[Marabout]], they were surrounded but refused to surrender. One of the French prisoners, [[adjutant]] Captain Dutertre, was then ordered to demand they comply, but instead urged them to fight to the death, and was promptly executed.


Over the next two days, the French fought off a series of assaults, but by 25 September were running low on ammunition and without water. They took advantage of a lull in the fighting to break out, but were caught by the Algerians three kilometres from Ghazaouet. This led to intense combat during which Géreaux was killed, and the French reduced to twenty men before being rescued by the local garrison. Some subsequently died of wounds or exhaustion and reports suggest only between eleven to sixteen men survived.
Over the next two days, the French fought off a series of assaults, but by 25 September were running low on ammunition and had no water left. Géreaux now decided to break out and and was only three kilometres from Ghazaouet, when the Algerians caught up. In the ensuing fight, Géreaux was killed and the French reduced to twenty men before being rescued by the local garrison. Some subsequently died of wounds or exhaustion and reports suggest only between eleven to sixteen men survived.


==Legacy==
The number of Algerian losses is unclear, but in September 2021, restoration work was completed on the tombs of 210 "martyrs" killed in the fighting.<ref>{{cite web |title=Noms des prisonniers dans la Deïra d'Abd el Kader Sidi-Brahim et Sidi-Moussa (1845-1846) |url=https://sidibrahim.canalblog.com/archives/2014/02/11/29188308.html |access-date=24 January 2025}}</ref>

==Aftermath==
[[File:Monument actuel, place d'armes à Oran..jpg|thumb|right|upright=0.8|Sidi-Brahim monument in Oran, now a memorial to Emir Abdelkader]]
[[File:Monument actuel, place d'armes à Oran..jpg|thumb|right|upright=0.8|Sidi-Brahim monument in Oran, now a memorial to Emir Abdelkader]]

The French [[Ministry of War (France)|Ministry of War]] subsequently issued a list of 141 officers and men taken prisoner at Sidi Brahim, along another 200 captured on 28 September just south of [[Aïn Témouchent]]. These prisoners were marched into [[Morocco]], where the majority died of wounds, disease, or were executed on 25 April 1846 by Moustapha Ben Tamy.<ref>{{cite web |title=Noms des prisonniers dans la Deïra d'Abd el Kader Sidi-Brahim et Sidi-Moussa (1845-1846) |url=https://sidibrahim.canalblog.com/archives/2014/02/11/29188308.html |access-date=24 January 2025}}</ref>


Despite their defeat, the French used the battle as a symbol of the "blood sacrifice" paid to create French Algeria. In 1898, a monument to the "martyrs of Sidi-Brahim" was erected in [[Oran]], but after [[Algerian War|Algerian independence]] in 1962, it was transformed into one of anti-colonial resistance, and the nationalist hero, Emir Abdelkader. Parts of the original monument were removed, including the statue of [[Marianne]], which can now be seen in the village of [[Périssac]], birthplace of Géreaux.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Ivey |first1=Beatrice |title=The Sidi-Brahim monument |url=https://pieds-noirs.stir.ac.uk/the-sidi-brahim-monument/ |website=Narratives and Representations of the French Settlers of Algeria |date=10 December 2018 |publisher=University of Stirling |access-date=28 December 2024}}</ref>
Despite their defeat, the French used the battle as a symbol of the "blood sacrifice" paid to create French Algeria. In 1898, a monument to the "martyrs of Sidi-Brahim" was erected in [[Oran]], but after [[Algerian War|Algerian independence]] in 1962, it was transformed into one of anti-colonial resistance, and the nationalist hero, Emir Abdelkader. Parts of the original monument were removed, including the statue of [[Marianne]], which can now be seen in the village of [[Périssac]], birthplace of Géreaux.<ref>{{cite web |last1=Ivey |first1=Beatrice |title=The Sidi-Brahim monument |url=https://pieds-noirs.stir.ac.uk/the-sidi-brahim-monument/ |website=Narratives and Representations of the French Settlers of Algeria |date=10 December 2018 |publisher=University of Stirling |access-date=28 December 2024}}</ref>

Revision as of 17:31, 24 January 2025

Battle of Sidi Brahim
Part of the French conquest of Algeria

Battle of Sidi Brahim by Louis-Théodore Devilly.
Date23–25 September 1845
Location
Result Algerian victory
Belligerents
 Kingdom of France Emirate of Mascara
Commanders and leaders
Lucien de Montagnac 
Captain Dutertre 
Captain de Géreaux 
Emir Abdelkader
Strength
500[1] 1,000 to 1,200[2]
Casualties and losses
489[1] Unknown

The Battle of Sidi Brahim, 23 to 25 September 1845, took place during the French conquest of Algeria, near Souahlia in Tlemcen Province. Between 1,000 to 1,200 Algerian irregulars under Emir Abdelkader ambushed a French detachment of 500 led by Lieutenant-Colonel Lucien de Montagnac. Most of the latter were killed in the initial fighting, and only eleven were reported to have ultimately survived the encounter.

Despite their defeat, the French used the battle as a symbol of the price paid to acquire French Algeria, and in 1898, a monument to the "martyrs of Sidi-Brahim" was installed in Oran. After Algerian independence in 1962, the monument was transformed into one commemorating Emir Abdelkader, and anti-colonial resistance in general.

Background

The French conquest of Algeria began with the capture of Algiers in 1830, and over the next decade expanded along the coast. In 1840, three French provinces were created, Constantine in the east, Alger in the centre, and Oran in the west. However, intense guerrilla fighting continued in the interior, headed in western Algeria by Emir Abdelkader. Although isolated French detachments were still vulnerable to surprise attacks, by 1845 a ruthless scorched earth policy employing small numbers of fast moving troops had eliminated most remaining resistance.[3]

In September 1845, Lieutenant-Colonel Lucien de Montagnac, commander of the garrison at Ghazaouet, was ordered to arrest Abdelkader, who was reported to be near Souahlia, twenty kilometres to the south. Taking six companies of light infantry and a squadron of hussars, totalling between 450 to 500 men, he left Ghazaouet on the night of 21 September. Allegedly unpopular with his troops, Montagnac was a hard-bitten colonial veteran, whose "own writings boast of several war crimes".[4]

Battle

On the evening of 22 September, the French made camp near Souahlia, and just after dawn on 23 September, Montagnac spotted a small force of Algerian cavalry in the distance. Leaving only two companies to guard the baggage, he led the rest of his detachment to intercept them. This proved to be a well-planned trap, and within minutes, the entire force was killed, including Montagnac. The French later estimated their opponents numbered over 3,000,[5] but Algerian sources suggest no more than 1,000 to 1,200.[2]

One of the two companies in reserve tried to rescue their comrades but was also overwhelmed, leaving 79 men from the 8th Carabinier Company under Captain Géreaux, along with six hussars. Retreating into a nearby monument to a local Marabout, they were surrounded but refused to surrender. One of the French prisoners, adjutant Captain Dutertre, was then ordered to demand they comply, but instead urged them to fight to the death, and was promptly executed.

Over the next two days, the French fought off a series of assaults, but by 25 September were running low on ammunition and had no water left. Géreaux now decided to break out and and was only three kilometres from Ghazaouet, when the Algerians caught up. In the ensuing fight, Géreaux was killed and the French reduced to twenty men before being rescued by the local garrison. Some subsequently died of wounds or exhaustion and reports suggest only between eleven to sixteen men survived.

Legacy

Sidi-Brahim monument in Oran, now a memorial to Emir Abdelkader

Despite their defeat, the French used the battle as a symbol of the "blood sacrifice" paid to create French Algeria. In 1898, a monument to the "martyrs of Sidi-Brahim" was erected in Oran, but after Algerian independence in 1962, it was transformed into one of anti-colonial resistance, and the nationalist hero, Emir Abdelkader. Parts of the original monument were removed, including the statue of Marianne, which can now be seen in the village of Périssac, birthplace of Géreaux.[6]

The remains of the French soldiers killed at Sidi Brahim were initially buried at Djemmaa Ghazaouet in the Tombeau des Braves. In 1965, these were transferred to the Musée des Chasseurs in Vincennes, and in 2000, a new memorial inaugurated as part of commemorations for the 155th anniversary of the battle.[7] The anniversary of the battle is still celebrated each year by Chasseur units of the French Army.[5]

Footnotes

References

  1. ^ a b Holstein 2019, p. 16.
  2. ^ a b Al Arabi 1986, p. 23.
  3. ^ Horne 1977, pp. 29–30.
  4. ^ Manceron 2003, p. 168.
  5. ^ a b Garnier 2004, p. 37.
  6. ^ Ivey, Beatrice (10 December 2018). "The Sidi-Brahim monument". Narratives and Representations of the French Settlers of Algeria. University of Stirling. Retrieved 28 December 2024.
  7. ^ "Le Mémorial - Fédération Nationale des Amicales de Chasseurs". Retrieved 23 January 2025.

Sources

  • Les Zouaves et les Chasseurs a Pied, Duc d'Aumale, Henri d'Orléans - pseudonym - M. Lévy frères - 1859 - 184 pages
  • Sidi-Brahim - 23, 24, 25 et 26 septembre 1845, Esquisse Historique - Charleville - Imprimerie Nouvelle - 1889 - 58 pages

35°15′38″N 0°34′03″W / 35.2606°N 0.5675°W / 35.2606; -0.5675