| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Miscellaneous comments |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Miscellaneous comments
|
| Fixed article a bit |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Fixed article a bit
|
| Two questions and clarifications |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Two questions and clarifications
|
| Image |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Image
|
| "String theory, as with any current theory of quantum gravity, is unverifiable, and therefore it is also unfalsifiable." |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#"String theory, as with any current theory of quantum gravity, is unverifiable, and therefore it is also unfalsifiable."
|
| Superstring theory |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Superstring theory
|
| what about the philosophy of a sphere? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#what about the philosophy of a sphere?
|
| garden hose thing |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#garden hose thing
|
| Not testable? |
9 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Not testable?
|
| Problem with String Theory Problems |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Problem with String Theory Problems
|
| What is wrong with string theory? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#What is wrong with string theory?
|
| Consciousness |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Consciousness
|
| people working on string theory |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#people working on string theory
|
| Question - Re Popper |
8 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Question - Re Popper
|
| False Vacuum Decay |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#False Vacuum Decay
|
| Some basic caveats added by 67.169.24.49 |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Some basic caveats added by 67.169.24.49
|
| Sidebar |
6 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Sidebar
|
| Pataphysics criticism added by 172.135.99.87 |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Pataphysics criticism added by 172.135.99.87
|
| Dimensions and Measurement. |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Dimensions and Measurement.
|
| Pataphysics a valid addition to the critical nomenclature of string theory |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Pataphysics a valid addition to the critical nomenclature of string theory
|
| Multiple Dimensions |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Multiple Dimensions
|
| String hypothesis? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#String hypothesis?
|
| "South Pole Neutrino Detector Could Yield Evidences of String Theory" |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#"South Pole Neutrino Detector Could Yield Evidences of String Theory"
|
| Anon comment |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Anon comment
|
| Weird anonymous deletions |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Weird anonymous deletions
|
| String theory is indeed testable and falsifiable and verifiable |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#String theory is indeed testable and falsifiable and verifiable
|
| deleting a formula |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#deleting a formula
|
| Falsifiable vs. predictive |
8 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Falsifiable vs. predictive
|
| Questionable sentence in "History" |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Questionable sentence in "History"
|
| Table corrected |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Table corrected
|
| string theory = B.S. |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#string theory = B.S.
|
| recent edits |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#recent edits
|
| "Evidence of string theory?" section |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#"Evidence of string theory?" section
|
| False history |
13 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#False history
|
| Editing the Overview |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Editing the Overview
|
| Can't edit Footnotes Section |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Can't edit Footnotes Section
|
| Brief Question |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Brief Question
|
| Edits made on 11th September |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Edits made on 11th September
|
| Just a question. |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Just a question.
|
| Made some corrections |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Made some corrections
|
| Number of Dimensions |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Number of Dimensions
|
| Model or Framework? |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Model or Framework?
|
| GA Re-Review and In-line citations |
6 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#GA Re-Review and In-line citations
|
| Question |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Question
|
| Archive Box |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Archive Box
|
| Assessment comment |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 1#Assessment comment
|
| Added Section |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Added Section
|
| The neutrality of this article is disputed. |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#The neutrality of this article is disputed.
|
| Added Sentence |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Added Sentence
|
| Information on extra dimensions? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Information on extra dimensions?
|
| A speculation on the 10 dimensions |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#A speculation on the 10 dimensions
|
| References and Popper |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#References and Popper
|
| Verifiability |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Verifiability
|
| "want to"? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#"want to"?
|
| Huh? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Huh?
|
| Introduction... |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Introduction...
|
| Analogy with Guitar Strings |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Analogy with Guitar Strings
|
| Eclipse |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Eclipse
|
| String Theory vs. Superstring Theory |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#String Theory vs. Superstring Theory
|
| Directly Testable Alternative to String Theory |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Directly Testable Alternative to String Theory
|
| Overview not up to standard |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Overview not up to standard
|
| Clarification |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Clarification
|
| Quantum strings ? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Quantum strings ?
|
| String theory stub |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#String theory stub
|
| New article on String duality ? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#New article on String duality ?
|
| Too much repetitive info. ? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Too much repetitive info. ?
|
| Mirman |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Mirman
|
| Asians? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Asians?
|
| Where are 'the same set of equations' ? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Where are 'the same set of equations' ?
|
| Supersymmetry and String Theory |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Supersymmetry and String Theory
|
| Removed dead link |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Removed dead link
|
| Thanks for that |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Thanks for that
|
| Predicted extra dimensions |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Predicted extra dimensions
|
| Last Edit |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Last Edit
|
| Problems with String Theory |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Problems with String Theory
|
| Background Independence |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Background Independence
|
| Technical Page? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Technical Page?
|
| Integrated Functionality??? |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Integrated Functionality???
|
| Some restraint in adding preprints |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Some restraint in adding preprints
|
| Website about String Theory and the 10 Dimensions. |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Website about String Theory and the 10 Dimensions.
|
| Princeton physicists connect string theory with established physics |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Princeton physicists connect string theory with established physics
|
| Uhhhh... Wow. |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Uhhhh... Wow.
|
| Testing String Theory |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Testing String Theory
|
| Removed an apparently incorrect quotation |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Removed an apparently incorrect quotation
|
| Removed quote |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Removed quote
|
| What is the meaning of the remark? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#What is the meaning of the remark?
|
| link to pseudoscientific explanation deleted |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#link to pseudoscientific explanation deleted
|
| Preface |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Preface
|
| Removed Line |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Removed Line
|
| String Theory is a tightly constrained theory? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#String Theory is a tightly constrained theory?
|
| A sensible quantum gravity? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#A sensible quantum gravity?
|
| Does string theory predict the number of space-time dimensions? |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Does string theory predict the number of space-time dimensions?
|
| guitar string analogy |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#guitar string analogy
|
| Added diagram |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Added diagram
|
| VERIFICATION, FALSIFICATION, PHILSOPHY OF SCIENCE AND STRING THEORY |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#VERIFICATION, FALSIFICATION, PHILSOPHY OF SCIENCE AND STRING THEORY
|
| Kaluza-Klein |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Kaluza-Klein
|
| Too much jargon? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Too much jargon?
|
| Unified Field Theory |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Unified Field Theory
|
| Opinion on "relative-ness" of extra dimensions? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Opinion on "relative-ness" of extra dimensions?
|
| Current/planned projects to find evidence of string theory section? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Current/planned projects to find evidence of string theory section?
|
| Description of an atom wrong |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Description of an atom wrong
|
| History of String Theory (& SUSY) |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#History of String Theory (& SUSY)
|
| Ten vs. Eleven |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Ten vs. Eleven
|
| Compact dimensions : Structure vs Holonomy |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Compact dimensions : Structure vs Holonomy
|
| New image |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#New image
|
| Loopholes and Implications |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Loopholes and Implications
|
| On Terminology |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#On Terminology
|
| Weaseling |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Weaseling
|
| Simplified version? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Simplified version?
|
| Nonsymmetric Tensor |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Nonsymmetric Tensor
|
| Tachyon has "imaginary" mass, or "negative" mass, or something else altogether? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#Tachyon has "imaginary" mass, or "negative" mass, or something else altogether?
|
| subatomic level |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 2#subatomic level
|
| lack of quantitative data |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#lack of quantitative data
|
| conceptual inconsistency |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#conceptual inconsistency
|
| Unreferenced speculation |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Unreferenced speculation
|
| History Section |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#History Section
|
| String Theory Makes No Predictions |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#String Theory Makes No Predictions
|
| Is string theory falsifiable? |
22 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Is string theory falsifiable?
|
| GA Reassessment |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#GA Reassessment
|
| Popular culture section |
28 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Popular culture section
|
| String theory is BS |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#String theory is BS
|
| Sparticles and Superpartners |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Sparticles and Superpartners
|
| an interesting article |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#an interesting article
|
| Mathematics of String theory |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Mathematics of String theory
|
| History section again |
12 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#History section again
|
| Something to consider ... |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Something to consider ...
|
| How Would You Find Strings? |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#How Would You Find Strings?
|
| Is string theory predictive? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Is string theory predictive?
|
| String theory, M-brane, whatever |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#String theory, M-brane, whatever
|
| Tags |
17 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Tags
|
| Theory, or Hypothesis? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Theory, or Hypothesis?
|
| What? |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#What?
|
| NO THEORY |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#NO THEORY
|
| I don't really get how strings work. |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#I don't really get how strings work.
|
| I don´t like the first picture |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#I don´t like the first picture
|
| Brane World scenario section |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Brane World scenario section
|
| What's new ? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#What's new ?
|
| Cutting the lead |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Cutting the lead
|
| Critical dimension and consistency |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#Critical dimension and consistency
|
| Consciousness as vibrating strings |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Consciousness as vibrating strings
|
| History |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 3#History
|
| Falsifiability |
7 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Falsifiability
|
| Exaggeration regarding testability and science |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Exaggeration regarding testability and science
|
| Construction |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Construction
|
| Possible strings as fibers instead of circles. |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Possible strings as fibers instead of circles.
|
| "11-dimensional space" was corrected to "11-dimensional spacetime" |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#"11-dimensional space" was corrected to "11-dimensional spacetime"
|
| Testable? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Testable?
|
| Good Article |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Good Article
|
| Formula? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Formula?
|
| How to test it. |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#How to test it.
|
| "Correct" |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#"Correct"
|
| How is the string theory scientific? |
10 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#How is the string theory scientific?
|
| Unified Strings (u21s19) Theory - NASA Conference Presentation |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Unified Strings (u21s19) Theory - NASA Conference Presentation
|
| Two small points on history |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Two small points on history
|
| widely believed to be consistant? |
6 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#widely believed to be consistant?
|
| Popper and testability |
19 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Popper and testability
|
| Popper testability following from testability of dependent theories. |
82 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 4#Popper testability following from testability of dependent theories.
|
| Other falsifications |
59 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Other falsifications
|
| New intro to prediction section |
6 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#New intro to prediction section
|
| " The theory has yet to make novel experimental predictions at accessible energy scales, leading some scientists to claim that it cannot be considered a part of science" |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#" The theory has yet to make novel experimental predictions at accessible energy scales, leading some scientists to claim that it cannot be considered a part of science"
|
| Missing word? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Missing word?
|
| The String Theory is not science |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#The String Theory is not science
|
| Edit request on 7 September 2012 |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Edit request on 7 September 2012
|
| New String Theory Website for the general public |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#New String Theory Website for the general public
|
| Uh... |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Uh...
|
| In layman terms, string theory is what? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#In layman terms, string theory is what?
|
| Unintelligible |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Unintelligible
|
| "Theory" vs. "research framework" |
12 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#"Theory" vs. "research framework"
|
| Little things... |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Little things...
|
| Why the refimprove tag ? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Why the refimprove tag ?
|
| The "Criticisms" section |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#The "Criticisms" section
|
| Three spatial dimensions implied (in inflation)? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 5#Three spatial dimensions implied (in inflation)?
|
| Unbalanced Criticism section & possibly more |
26 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Unbalanced Criticism section & possibly more
|
| A lack of mathematical language |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#A lack of mathematical language
|
| A clear explanation of the problems it solves is needed |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#A clear explanation of the problems it solves is needed
|
| One dimentional? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#One dimentional?
|
| Explanations |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Explanations
|
| "Failure" claim appears unsupported |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#"Failure" claim appears unsupported
|
| Lede, re gravity: Is "Besides this potential role..." redundant? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Lede, re gravity: Is "Besides this potential role..." redundant?
|
| 11 dimensions (11-dimensional) |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#11 dimensions (11-dimensional)
|
| String Theory/Quantum Physics |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#String Theory/Quantum Physics
|
| String theory proven? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#String theory proven?
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#External links modified
|
| Krauss quote |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Krauss quote
|
| Phenomenology |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Phenomenology
|
| Superstring Theory 10-Dimensions and Supergravity Theory 11-Dimensions |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Superstring Theory 10-Dimensions and Supergravity Theory 11-Dimensions
|
| This article has a conspicuous lack of mathematical language |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#This article has a conspicuous lack of mathematical language
|
| non causal and axiomatic if not evolved |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#non causal and axiomatic if not evolved
|
| Is it a theory? |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Is it a theory?
|
| proof of string theory or multidimensional universe? |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#proof of string theory or multidimensional universe?
|
| Extra Dimensions |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Extra Dimensions
|
| THERE IS A PHYSICAL FOUNDATION FOR STRING THEORY |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#THERE IS A PHYSICAL FOUNDATION FOR STRING THEORY
|
| Source 84 versus claim |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Source 84 versus claim
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 2 September 2018 |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 2 September 2018
|
| Move to quantum strings |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Move to quantum strings
|
| Intro |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Intro
|
| Extra Dimensions: 6D or 7D hyperspace + common 4D = 10/11D spacetime |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Extra Dimensions: 6D or 7D hyperspace + common 4D = 10/11D spacetime
|
| Michio Kaku |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Michio Kaku
|
| Invitation to submit to the WikiJournal of Science |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Invitation to submit to the WikiJournal of Science
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 15 February 2019 |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 15 February 2019
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 29 March 2019 |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 29 March 2019
|
| Popularization |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Popularization
|
| String Theory is not a Scientific Theory with regards to Popper |
9 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#String Theory is not a Scientific Theory with regards to Popper
|
| "Yarn theory" listed at Redirects for discussion |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#"Yarn theory" listed at Redirects for discussion
|
| Grammar Error |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Grammar Error
|
| Experimental Evidence and Falsifiability Criterion |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Experimental Evidence and Falsifiability Criterion
|
| Witten |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Witten
|
| Brevity and clarity |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Brevity and clarity
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 10 April 2022 |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 10 April 2022
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 10 May 2022 |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Semi-protected edit request on 10 May 2022
|
| First and Second Revolution? What was overthrown? Who was anointed to coin these exaggerations? |
3 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#First and Second Revolution? What was overthrown? Who was anointed to coin these exaggerations?
|
| Title should be "String hypothesis" |
5 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Title should be "String hypothesis"
|
| Any connection to matter waves? |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Any connection to matter waves?
|
| Dead Link |
2 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#Dead Link
|
| This article unrealistically hides string theory weakness |
4 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#This article unrealistically hides string theory weakness
|
| add mention of criticism to summary paragraph |
1 |
Talk:String theory/Archive 6#add mention of criticism to summary paragraph
|
| Why must everything be particle-based? |
7 |
Talk:String theory#Why must everything be particle-based?
|
| Dyson's view of String Theory. |
8 |
Talk:String theory#Dyson's view of String Theory.
|
| Overview section is pop-science, not encyclopedic. |
2 |
Talk:String theory#Overview section is pop-science, not encyclopedic.
|
| a string will look just like an ordinary particle |
5 |
Talk:String theory#a string will look just like an ordinary particle
|
| Examples of Realistic Physics could be added to Particle Physics Section? |
3 |
Talk:String theory#Examples of Realistic Physics could be added to Particle Physics Section?
|
