| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Old testament |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Old testament
|
| Economic and Social system |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Economic and Social system
|
| "Canaanites" as earliest inhabitants |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#"Canaanites" as earliest inhabitants
|
| Canaanites descended from Ham |
33 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Canaanites descended from Ham
|
| Israel or Palestine for the region? |
30 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Israel or Palestine for the region?
|
| Off topic? |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Off topic?
|
| Regional Name |
12 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Regional Name
|
| What does Cypherx REALLY want? |
11 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#What does Cypherx REALLY want?
|
| Teaching Cypherx history: This article is NOT about "Prehistory" |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Teaching Cypherx history: This article is NOT about "Prehistory"
|
| Israel-Palestine, anyone? |
19 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Israel-Palestine, anyone?
|
| "scholarly" |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#"scholarly"
|
| History of ancient Israel Series or Kingdom of Israel series? |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#History of ancient Israel Series or Kingdom of Israel series?
|
| Definition of minimalists and maximalists. |
8 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Definition of minimalists and maximalists.
|
| Tanakh |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Tanakh
|
| Anon addition |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Anon addition
|
| Thanks |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Thanks
|
| Map of 1st Century Palestine |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Map of 1st Century Palestine
|
| Tanakh does not claim the original inhabitants were Shemites |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Tanakh does not claim the original inhabitants were Shemites
|
| Other articles and duplication of information - Opinions? |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Other articles and duplication of information - Opinions?
|
| Chart at bottom of page? |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Chart at bottom of page?
|
| Historicity |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Historicity
|
| money paid for the land of Israel |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#money paid for the land of Israel
|
| hmmm |
10 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#hmmm
|
| Reference |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Reference
|
| History of ancient Israel and Judah (1000-63 BCE) |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#History of ancient Israel and Judah (1000-63 BCE)
|
| Point of View |
24 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Point of View
|
| Santorini volcano? |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Santorini volcano?
|
| The lead |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#The lead
|
| Pre-history is not part of ISRAEL and JUDAH's history |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Pre-history is not part of ISRAEL and JUDAH's history
|
| Corrections |
6 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Corrections
|
| Origins of the name Israel |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Origins of the name Israel
|
| Removed lost tribes text |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 1#Removed lost tribes text
|
| Consort |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Consort
|
| Merging with article Pre-Roman history of ancient Israel and Judah |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Merging with article Pre-Roman history of ancient Israel and Judah
|
| Persian Yehud |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Persian Yehud
|
| This is no History |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#This is no History
|
| Very Little History |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Very Little History
|
| Deleted Old Testament Genealogy |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Deleted Old Testament Genealogy
|
| Biblical timelines |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Biblical timelines
|
| Much opinion little scholarship |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Much opinion little scholarship
|
| Qumran |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Qumran
|
| Israelites' Monotheism |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Israelites' Monotheism
|
| Invitation for discussion re historical issue on ancient Israel |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Invitation for discussion re historical issue on ancient Israel
|
| Weasel words |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Weasel words
|
| History of Ancient Israel and Judah- Exodus # |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#History of Ancient Israel and Judah- Exodus #
|
| Dever quote off topic |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Dever quote off topic
|
| What kind of history is this? |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#What kind of history is this?
|
| Ancient Egyptian domination |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Ancient Egyptian domination
|
| The Ethiopian source mentioned |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#The Ethiopian source mentioned
|
| Implications of the newly discovered ostracon |
8 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Implications of the newly discovered ostracon
|
| Chronological precision |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Chronological precision
|
| Archeologist claims proof of Israelites leaving Egypt and entering Canaan |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Archeologist claims proof of Israelites leaving Egypt and entering Canaan
|
| Further reading |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Further reading
|
| Judah and Palestine |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Judah and Palestine
|
| Reorganisation |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Reorganisation
|
| Finkelstein? |
8 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Finkelstein?
|
| The Levant term |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#The Levant term
|
| Merge Pre Roman into this article |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Merge Pre Roman into this article
|
| Removed Referenced Statements |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Removed Referenced Statements
|
| PiCo's edits |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#PiCo's edits
|
| The emergence of Israel |
17 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#The emergence of Israel
|
| Serious problem |
13 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Serious problem
|
| Merneptah Stele |
25 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Merneptah Stele
|
| How to present the biblical literalist view |
17 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#How to present the biblical literalist view
|
| Canaanite language |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Canaanite language
|
| Canaanite language II |
16 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Canaanite language II
|
| ": As per Doug's request, deleting next sentence for consideration, see talk." |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#": As per Doug's request, deleting next sentence for consideration, see talk."
|
| Excuse me |
11 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Excuse me
|
| 1209 |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#1209
|
| Hellenistic period |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Hellenistic period
|
| Congratulations |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Congratulations
|
| Conformity/verification of sources |
79 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Conformity/verification of sources
|
| Was Mark Smith actually there? |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Was Mark Smith actually there?
|
| One month |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#One month
|
| Third opinion request |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Third opinion request
|
| Chieftains of the highland clans |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Chieftains of the highland clans
|
| Tagging |
13 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 2#Tagging
|
| Sources: bible |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Sources: bible
|
| (If "southern Levant" (source Golden) does not mean "Negev", or if "non-biblical works" (source PiCo) does not mean "non-biblical narratives", well, excuuse me. Thank you for your attention.) |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#(If "southern Levant" (source Golden) does not mean "Negev", or if "non-biblical works" (source PiCo) does not mean "non-biblical narratives", well, excuuse me. Thank you for your attention.)
|
| 2nd para of section Late Bronze Age |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#2nd para of section Late Bronze Age
|
| Tag: Slanted towards recent events |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Tag: Slanted towards recent events
|
| Bibliography |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Bibliography
|
| Reversion of John Bulten's edit on Iron I |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Reversion of John Bulten's edit on Iron I
|
| Sources |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Sources
|
| Edits to Iron I section |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Edits to Iron I section
|
| Emergence: Competing Theories |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Emergence: Competing Theories
|
| Iron I again |
6 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Iron I again
|
| Iron I again again |
8 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Iron I again again
|
| Section "Iron Age I" consensus text |
32 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 3#Section "Iron Age I" consensus text
|
| Para added to Iron I section re theories on emergence of Israel |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Para added to Iron I section re theories on emergence of Israel
|
| New edit list |
58 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#New edit list
|
| PiCo and Dylan Flaherty are sockpuppets (or more probable close associates)?? |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#PiCo and Dylan Flaherty are sockpuppets (or more probable close associates)??
|
| Addressing John's problems |
22 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Addressing John's problems
|
| Closure |
23 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Closure
|
| Iron ages |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Iron ages
|
| Use of the term Palestine |
20 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Use of the term Palestine
|
| Section "Religion" |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Section "Religion"
|
| Mediation Cabal case |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Mediation Cabal case
|
| Judges Period |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Judges Period
|
| A request for help |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#A request for help
|
| Biassed Perspective |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Biassed Perspective
|
| Disruptive editing by Tritomex |
5 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Disruptive editing by Tritomex
|
| Accuracy of religion section |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Accuracy of religion section
|
| Abraham and Moses |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Abraham and Moses
|
| removals of valid facts |
9 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#removals of valid facts
|
| severe lack of photos and illustrations in the article |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#severe lack of photos and illustrations in the article
|
| Reliability of claim on biblical historicity |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Reliability of claim on biblical historicity
|
| Reference to two steles deleted |
6 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Reference to two steles deleted
|
| Josephus |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Josephus
|
| File:Asherah.jpg Nominated for Deletion |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#File:Asherah.jpg Nominated for Deletion
|
| Article's Default Era |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Article's Default Era
|
| Section "The archaeological record" |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Section "The archaeological record"
|
| Archaeological record revisited |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Archaeological record revisited
|
| "whereas the Bible had depicted them as monotheists from the beginning" |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#"whereas the Bible had depicted them as monotheists from the beginning"
|
| Removal of section on sources |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Removal of section on sources
|
| Verification |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Verification
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#External links modified
|
| "Hebraism" |
12 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#"Hebraism"
|
| August 20 edits |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#August 20 edits
|
| "peaceful" claim |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#"peaceful" claim
|
| "peaceful" and "internal" |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#"peaceful" and "internal"
|
| POV claim falsely constructed from clear quote |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#POV claim falsely constructed from clear quote
|
| Proposed content |
10 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Proposed content
|
| Map - source added to map page doesn't match the map |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Map - source added to map page doesn't match the map
|
| Sources |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Sources
|
| "First Temple period" autolinks here, but there isn't a single mention of the term in the article |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#"First Temple period" autolinks here, but there isn't a single mention of the term in the article
|
| Many sections are myth |
3 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Many sections are myth
|
| Bibliography cleanup details |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Bibliography cleanup details
|
| Evidence for 10th century BC Judah |
14 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#Evidence for 10th century BC Judah
|
| Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 4#Wiki Education Foundation-supported course assignment
|
| Change to lede to emphasise Israelite presence in the region |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#Change to lede to emphasise Israelite presence in the region
|
| On Kingdom of Israel (Samaria) |
7 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#On Kingdom of Israel (Samaria)
|
| "Ancient Israel" listed at Redirects for discussion |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#"Ancient Israel" listed at Redirects for discussion
|
| Scope of this article |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#Scope of this article
|
| Frevel’s new SBL textbook “History of Ancient Israel” |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#Frevel’s new SBL textbook “History of Ancient Israel”
|
| Somewhat confusing title |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah#Somewhat confusing title
|
| Define the period |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah#Define the period
|
| Late Bronze and Iron I: years |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah/Archive 5#Late Bronze and Iron I: years
|
| Why do we need this article? or: critical review of the article |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah#Why do we need this article? or: critical review of the article
|
| Fringe |
4 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah#Fringe
|
| communists taking power in Poland after 1945 |
2 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah#communists taking power in Poland after 1945
|
| First Temple period |
1 |
Talk:History of ancient Israel and Judah#First Temple period
|
