| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Initial comments |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Initial comments
|
| Section "Overview" |
17 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Section "Overview"
|
| Criticism |
8 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Criticism
|
| New Particles |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#New Particles
|
| Stub Status? |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Stub Status?
|
| E8 vs e8 |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#E8 vs e8
|
| Lisi's claim of unification is not verified |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Lisi's claim of unification is not verified
|
| Structure of article |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Structure of article
|
| Overview revisited (in laymen's terms) |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Overview revisited (in laymen's terms)
|
| Technical description and criticism |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Technical description and criticism
|
| A Layman's Explanation section |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#A Layman's Explanation section
|
| E8 X E8 X E8 |
7 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#E8 X E8 X E8
|
| Masses |
12 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Masses
|
| Another blogger |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Another blogger
|
| Edit war? |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Edit war?
|
| Fermions and bosons again |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Fermions and bosons again
|
| "An error" according to Distler |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#"An error" according to Distler
|
| Notability |
9 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Notability
|
| E8 lattice? |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#E8 lattice?
|
| Clean-up and rewrite (1 Jan 2008) |
15 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Clean-up and rewrite (1 Jan 2008)
|
| Lisi work Aether Wave Theory interpetation - please, correct it, if you like it, delete it, if not |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Lisi work Aether Wave Theory interpetation - please, correct it, if you like it, delete it, if not
|
| There is an AfD that might interest you guys |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#There is an AfD that might interest you guys
|
| Recent reverts / "no new Einstein |
6 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 1#Recent reverts / "no new Einstein
|
| Various Changes |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Various Changes
|
| Putting theory to the test section |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Putting theory to the test section
|
| NB re falsifiability |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#NB re falsifiability
|
| pun |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#pun
|
| sautoy |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#sautoy
|
| this article is violation of Wikipedia's policy regarding original research |
7 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#this article is violation of Wikipedia's policy regarding original research
|
| Unpublished Work |
9 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Unpublished Work
|
| Why Are Winners of the Fields Medal's Comments Not Allowed? |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Why Are Winners of the Fields Medal's Comments Not Allowed?
|
| Is Scientific American Not Considered a Valid Source? |
11 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Is Scientific American Not Considered a Valid Source?
|
| Chronology |
11 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Chronology
|
| Introduction discussion |
12 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Introduction discussion
|
| Name of the theory, or the pre-print? |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Name of the theory, or the pre-print?
|
| Chronology (2) |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Chronology (2)
|
| Scientific american source |
7 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Scientific american source
|
| Fringe theory noticeboard |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Fringe theory noticeboard
|
| No more chronology? |
14 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#No more chronology?
|
| Edit war over last paragraph of intro |
15 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Edit war over last paragraph of intro
|
| Overview rewrite |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Overview rewrite
|
| about 20 new particles ? |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#about 20 new particles ?
|
| Clarify source for "most-downloaded" statement? |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 2#Clarify source for "most-downloaded" statement?
|
| Version by IP 66.93.186.140 |
6 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Version by IP 66.93.186.140
|
| Two-dimensional sphere? |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Two-dimensional sphere?
|
| N=8 Supergravity |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#N=8 Supergravity
|
| Version by IP 169.231.42.148 |
19 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Version by IP 169.231.42.148
|
| Edit of reference by SCZenz |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Edit of reference by SCZenz
|
| Reply to Scientryst |
8 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Reply to Scientryst
|
| New grant awarded to Lisi |
9 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#New grant awarded to Lisi
|
| Edits by IP 169.231.42.148 |
6 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Edits by IP 169.231.42.148
|
| Don't go for arbitration! |
6 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Don't go for arbitration!
|
| Now The NY Times Is Not Considered a Valid Source |
7 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Now The NY Times Is Not Considered a Valid Source
|
| Why Are Winners of the Fields Medal's Comments Not Allowed? |
19 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Why Are Winners of the Fields Medal's Comments Not Allowed?
|
| Citations |
9 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Citations
|
| Problems with the theory should be listed in one place |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Problems with the theory should be listed in one place
|
| Input From The General Public (interested in Science, but not schooled in Science) |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 3#Input From The General Public (interested in Science, but not schooled in Science)
|
| Distler-Garibaldi |
19 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Distler-Garibaldi
|
| Requested move |
13 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Requested move
|
| Split |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Split
|
| Lots of minor edits |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Lots of minor edits
|
| "Banned user" revert |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#"Banned user" revert
|
| called E8 Theory? |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#called E8 Theory?
|
| Heavy paragraph |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Heavy paragraph
|
| An Explicit Embedding of Gravity and the Standard Model in E8 |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#An Explicit Embedding of Gravity and the Standard Model in E8
|
| Recent Developments |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Recent Developments
|
| The Greater Goal of The Smolin-Lisi Enterprise? |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#The Greater Goal of The Smolin-Lisi Enterprise?
|
| A Sci Am Dec 2010 E8 article typo? |
7 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#A Sci Am Dec 2010 E8 article typo?
|
| This is a dangerous page, to be maybe observed by admins or people that avoid some edit wars? |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#This is a dangerous page, to be maybe observed by admins or people that avoid some edit wars?
|
| Should a Section Be Introduced Discussing How All This is Media Hype? |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Should a Section Be Introduced Discussing How All This is Media Hype?
|
| What is the purpose of hiding the truth? |
22 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#What is the purpose of hiding the truth?
|
| Wikilink Stéphane Foucart ? |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#Wikilink Stéphane Foucart ?
|
| More changes |
37 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 4#More changes
|
| I'm lost |
15 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#I'm lost
|
| New draft |
15 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#New draft
|
| This article must be deleted. |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#This article must be deleted.
|
| Last revert |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#Last revert
|
| The Greater Goal of The Smolin-Lisi Enterprise? |
19 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#The Greater Goal of The Smolin-Lisi Enterprise?
|
| Exceptionally simple????? |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#Exceptionally simple?????
|
| Removal of Description section |
46 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#Removal of Description section
|
| WP:COI Conflict of Interest |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 5#WP:COI Conflict of Interest
|
| Let's summarize |
7 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Let's summarize
|
| New Version |
3 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#New Version
|
| Article Strongly Violates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:No original research No Original Research |
8 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Article Strongly Violates http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:No original research No Original Research
|
| The Lisi/Smolin Affair Redux |
9 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#The Lisi/Smolin Affair Redux
|
| OK, let's tackle the lede and the chronology section. |
11 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#OK, let's tackle the lede and the chronology section.
|
| 71.106.167.55 (and also 98.244.55.28?), who are you anyway? |
5 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#71.106.167.55 (and also 98.244.55.28?), who are you anyway?
|
| Propose title change |
11 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Propose title change
|
| Fringe Theories noticeboard |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Fringe Theories noticeboard
|
| Lisi using Smolin-funded Social Media Network to Harass/Out/Namecall Wikipedia Editors |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Lisi using Smolin-funded Social Media Network to Harass/Out/Namecall Wikipedia Editors
|
| Time for Scientryst/Lisi/Smolin/SherryNugil/Sockpuppet to Share their massive COIs |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Time for Scientryst/Lisi/Smolin/SherryNugil/Sockpuppet to Share their massive COIs
|
| Delightful! |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Delightful!
|
| More Erroneous Garrett Lisi Attempts at Outing Wikipedia Editors Garrett's Google + Network |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#More Erroneous Garrett Lisi Attempts at Outing Wikipedia Editors Garrett's Google + Network
|
| Dear Garrett Lisi, Wikipedia is not the place where to directly describe your own theory or your own person. |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Dear Garrett Lisi, Wikipedia is not the place where to directly describe your own theory or your own person.
|
| Warning |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Warning
|
| Precedent |
25 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 6#Precedent
|
| Removed section: Visual representation |
44 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 7#Removed section: Visual representation
|
| Article length - try to be constructive, please |
16 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 7#Article length - try to be constructive, please
|
| Advertisement, promotion and original research. |
6 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 7#Advertisement, promotion and original research.
|
| Lisi's Once-Main Proponents Lee Smolin & Peter Woit Now Abandoning Lisi/Lisipedia in 2012 |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 7#Lisi's Once-Main Proponents Lee Smolin & Peter Woit Now Abandoning Lisi/Lisipedia in 2012
|
| Does Wikipedia need this article and, if so, what form should it take? |
18 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 7#Does Wikipedia need this article and, if so, what form should it take?
|
| Critiques |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything/Archive 7#Critiques
|
| Who is Lisi? |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything#Who is Lisi?
|
| Helpful till Highschool students. |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything#Helpful till Highschool students.
|
| Update |
1 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything#Update
|
| Not good at Wikipedia, but I have a suggested change |
2 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything#Not good at Wikipedia, but I have a suggested change
|
| Model not notable; technical details not note-worthy. Please prune |
10 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything#Model not notable; technical details not note-worthy. Please prune
|
| Picture of Lisi? |
4 |
Talk:An Exceptionally Simple Theory of Everything#Picture of Lisi?
|
