Help:Citation Style 1/test problems

This is an essay.

It contains the advice or opinions of one or more Wikipedia contributors. This page is not an encyclopedia article, nor is it one of Wikipedia's policies or guidelines, as it has not been thoroughly vetted by the community. Some essays represent widespread norms; others only represent minority viewpoints.

This page, for Citation Style 1 cite templates, contains testcases to show specific problems and potential solution.

Method: The testcases, below, show examples of noted problems in operation, in specific form, although not all problems are shown here. In practice, the most crucial data is the common live data; however, unusual problems should be remembered, noted, and perhaps solutions can be found as needed.

Testcases for Cite_journal

When there is an author/editor, then "date=" should follow that in "(...)" but without author/editor when only "title=" then date should precede the page-number, or when "journal=" (or "periodical="), date should immediately follow the page number (before showing any "arxiv=" data).

Cite journal comparison
Wikitext	`{{cite journal\|date=1 May 1998\|issue=Issue\|pages=3456-59\|title=Test Cite_journal title only}}`
Live	"Test Cite_journal title only" (Issue). 1 May 1998: 3456–59. `{{cite journal}}`: `\|issue=` has extra text (help); Cite journal requires `\|journal=` (help)
Sandbox	"Test Cite_journal title only" (Issue). 1 May 1998: 3456–59. `{{cite journal}}`: `\|issue=` has extra text (help); Cite journal requires `\|journal=` (help)

Cite journal comparison
Wikitext	`{{cite journal\|date=7 June 2012\|issue=Issue\|pages=3456-59\|title=Test Cite_journal title+work\|work=Journal Name}}`
Live	"Test Cite_journal title+work". Journal Name (Issue): 3456–59. 7 June 2012. `{{cite journal}}`: `\|issue=` has extra text (help)
Sandbox	"Test Cite_journal title+work". Journal Name (Issue): 3456–59. 7 June 2012. `{{cite journal}}`: `\|issue=` has extra text (help)

Sandbox: "Test Cite_journal title+work". Journal Name (Issue): 3456–59. 7 June 2012. {{cite journal}}: |issue= has extra text (help); Invalid |mode=journal (help)

Placement of other parameters has been shifted, slightly different from {cite_journal/old}. All parameters for {cite_journal}:

Cite journal comparison
Wikitext	{{cite journal\|accessdate=Accessdate\|agency=Agency\|archivedate=Archivedate\|archiveurl=http://archiveurl.com\|arxiv=ArXiv\|asin-tld=ASIN-tld\|asin=ASIN\|at=at\|author-link=Hyperlink#author\|author=Author\|bibcode=Bibcode\|coauthor=Coauthor\|date=Date\|deadurl=deadurl\|department=Department\|doi=10.DOI\|doi_inactivedate=doi_inactivedate\|edition=Evening\|format=Format\|id=Id\|isbn=Isbn\|issn=Issn\|issue=Issue\|jfm=JFM\|journal=Journal Name\|jstor=Jstor\|language=Language\|laydate=Laydate\|laysource=Laysource\|laysummary=Laysummary\|lccn=LCCN\|mr=MR\|oclc=OCLC\|origyear=Origyear\|osti=OSTI\|others=Others\|page=page\|pages=B4\|place=Place\|pmc=PMC\|pmid=PMID\|postscript=Postscript\|publisher=Publisher\|quote=Quote\|ref=harv\|rfc=RFC\|series=Series\|ssrn=SSRN\|subscription=Subscription\|title=Test Cite_journal Parameters\|titlelink=Hyperlink#title\|trans_title=trans_title\|transcript=Transcript\|transcripturl=http://transcripturl.com\|type=Type\|url=http://url.com\|via=Via\|volume=Volume\|zbl=ZBL}}
Live	Author (Date) [Origyear]. "Test Cite_journal Parameters". Department. Journal Name (Type). Series (in Language). Volume (Issue). Others (Evening ed.). Place: Publisher: page. arXiv:ArXiv. ASIN ASIN. Bibcode:Bibcode. doi:10.DOI. ISBN Isbn. ISSN Issn. JFM JFM. JSTOR Jstor. LCCN LCCN. MR MR. OCLC OCLC. OSTI OSTI. PMC PMC. PMID PMID. RFC RFC. SSRN SSRN. Zbl ZBL. Id. Archived from the original (Format) on Archivedate. Retrieved Accessdate – via Via. Quote `{{cite journal}}`: `\|author=` has generic name (help); `\|issue=` has extra text (help); `\|page=` has extra text (help); `\|volume=` has extra text (help); Check `\|arxiv=` value (help); Check `\|asin-tld=` value (help); Check `\|asin=` value (help); Check `\|bibcode=` length (help); Check `\|doi=` value (help); Check `\|isbn=` value: invalid character (help); Check `\|issn=` value (help); Check `\|jfm=` value (help); Check `\|jstor=` value (help); Check `\|lccn=` value (help); Check `\|mr=` value (help); Check `\|oclc=` value (help); Check `\|osti=` value (help); Check `\|pmc=` value (help); Check `\|pmid=` value (help); Check `\|rfc=` value (help); Check `\|ssrn=` value (help); Check `\|zbl=` value (help); Check date values in: `\|accessdate=`, `\|date=`, and `\|archivedate=` (help); External link in `\|transcripturl=` (help); Invalid `\|ref=harv` (help); More than one of `\|pages=`, `\|at=`, and `\|page=` specified (help); Unknown parameter `\|agency=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|coauthor=` ignored (`\|author=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|deadurl=` ignored (`\|url-status=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|doi_inactivedate=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|laydate=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|laysource=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|laysummary=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|subscription=` ignored (`\|url-access=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|titlelink=` ignored (`\|title-link=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|trans_title=` ignored (`\|trans-title=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|transcript=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|transcripturl=` ignored (help)CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)
Sandbox	Author (Date) [Origyear]. "Test Cite_journal Parameters". Department. Journal Name (Type). Series (in Language). Volume (Issue). Others (Evening ed.). Place: Publisher: page. arXiv:ArXiv. ASIN ASIN. Bibcode:Bibcode. doi:10.DOI. ISBN Isbn. ISSN Issn. JFM JFM. JSTOR Jstor. LCCN LCCN. MR MR. OCLC OCLC. OSTI OSTI. PMC PMC. PMID PMID. RFC RFC. SSRN SSRN. Zbl ZBL. Id. Archived from the original (Format) on Archivedate. Retrieved Accessdate – via Via. Quote `{{cite journal}}`: `\|author=` has generic name (help); `\|issue=` has extra text (help); `\|page=` has extra text (help); `\|volume=` has extra text (help); Check `\|arxiv=` value (help); Check `\|asin-tld=` value (help); Check `\|asin=` value (help); Check `\|bibcode=` length (help); Check `\|doi=` value (help); Check `\|isbn=` value: invalid character (help); Check `\|issn=` value (help); Check `\|jfm=` value (help); Check `\|jstor=` value (help); Check `\|lccn=` value (help); Check `\|mr=` value (help); Check `\|oclc=` value (help); Check `\|osti=` value (help); Check `\|pmc=` value (help); Check `\|pmid=` value (help); Check `\|rfc=` value (help); Check `\|ssrn=` value (help); Check `\|zbl=` value (help); Check date values in: `\|accessdate=`, `\|date=`, and `\|archivedate=` (help); Invalid `\|ref=harv` (help); More than one of `\|pages=`, `\|at=`, and `\|page=` specified (help); Unknown parameter `\|agency=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|coauthor=` ignored (`\|author=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|deadurl=` ignored (`\|url-status=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|doi_inactivedate=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|laydate=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|laysource=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|laysummary=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|subscription=` ignored (`\|url-access=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|titlelink=` ignored (`\|title-link=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|trans_title=` ignored (`\|trans-title=` suggested) (help); Unknown parameter `\|transcript=` ignored (help); Unknown parameter `\|transcripturl=` ignored (help)CS1 maint: unrecognized language (link)