Wikipedia:WikipediaWeekly/Episode69

Episode 69: Wikipedia under the Microscope Released: TBD 2009

Downloads

All episodes, including options to automatically subscribe via RSS or iTunes, are at wikipedia weekly.org.

MP3 and OGG versions are available for all episodes and comments can be left at this episode's page.

Participants:

• Fuzheado
• Witty Lama
• Tawker
• Durova
• Ragesoss
• Jdforrester

Others?

• Phoebe
• Danny

Roundtable Topics

• This week in Censorship
• RNA Biology - science journal requires authors to edit Wikipedia
• Wikipedians grumpy and closed-minded?
• Admin uses ability to view deleted edits to obtain test "answer key", posts on Facebook
• Philosopher finds that Wikipedia has good "epistemic consequences"
• Add more here

Podcaster's Picks

• Fuzheado: BART Police shooting of Oscar Grant (and see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/2009 BART Police Shooting)
• Ragesoss: Big Science (and see Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Big Science)
• Choice of article could be launching point into bigger discussion below, or something you find interesting

Critical Issues and 2009 Predictions

• Deletionism
  • IS Wikipedia news/journalism, distinction?
  • Wikipedia becoming more like a conventional encyclopedia?
  • Effects of deletion (discourages authors, maintains exemplar standards, restores low-hanging fruit, destroys quirky content that flourished early on...)
  • Jimbo in 2003: "if someone wants to write an article about their high school, we should relax and accommodate them" (see this current AfD)
  • Fourth time's a charm?
• Policies in conflict? Phil Sandifer's argument that NPOV and NOR contradict for some types of content (especially in the humanities)
• Arbitration

• Conflict of interest, undue influence?
  • Rick Warren and The Purpose Driven Life
• Stratification of Wikipedian society?