Wikipedia:Historical archive/Policy/Notability/Notability changes: Revision history

13 July 2024

• curprev 15:5515:55, 13 July 2024 Hex talk contribs m 7,569 bytes 0 Scott moved page Wikipedia:Notability/Historical/Notability changes to Wikipedia:Historical archive/Policy/Notability/Notability changes: Add to collection of policy pages in the historical archive undo

12 March 2023

• curprev 23:3823:38, 12 March 2023 Legobot talk contribs m 7,569 bytes +4 Bot: Fixing lint errors, replacing obsolete HTML tags: <tt> (1x) undo Tag: Fixed lint errors

29 December 2006

• curprev 13:3513:35, 29 December 2006 Radiant! talk contribs 7,565 bytes −64 historical, not a criterion undo

11 December 2006

• curprev 05:0205:02, 11 December 2006 SMcCandlish talk contribs m 7,629 bytes 0 moved Wikipedia:Notability proposal to Wikipedia:Notability/Historical/Notability changes: Archiving all the old notability proposals in the centralized place. undo

11 January 2006

• curprev 03:4903:49, 11 January 2006 EddieSegoura talk contribs 7,629 bytes −301 →Con: rm comment, belongs in discussion undo
• curprev 03:4903:49, 11 January 2006 EddieSegoura talk contribs 7,930 bytes +301 →Con: disagree undo

30 December 2005

• curprev 13:3413:34, 30 December 2005 Radiant! talk contribs 7,629 bytes +224 {{historical}} - discussion died down undo

8 November 2005

• curprev 17:1317:13, 8 November 2005 Unfocused talk contribs 7,405 bytes −14 →Con: "things or themselves" --> "topics". Articles are about topics. undo
• curprev 16:1016:10, 8 November 2005 Trollderella talk contribs 7,419 bytes +102 →Con undo

29 October 2005

• curprev 02:0202:02, 29 October 2005 Trollderella talk contribs 7,317 bytes +11 Added 'to someone', to clarify undo

28 October 2005

• curprev 02:4302:43, 28 October 2005 72.240.220.204 talk 7,306 bytes +108 →Con: note Amazon search in Books for "encyclopedia" yields over 27,000 results undo
• curprev 02:4102:41, 28 October 2005 72.240.220.204 talk 7,198 bytes +11 →Con: consensus --> predefined consensus. We've found rough consensus before, we do every day. But cannot define it in advance. undo

27 October 2005

• curprev 14:4314:43, 27 October 2005 Unfocused talk contribs 7,187 bytes +31 →Con: notability is a POV. undo

13 October 2005

• curprev 07:3007:30, 13 October 2005 Graham87 talk contribs m 7,156 bytes 0 →Pro: than/then undo
• curprev 04:1804:18, 13 October 2005 Interiot talk contribs m 7,156 bytes +64 Notability category undo
• curprev 00:2500:25, 13 October 2005 Reinyday talk contribs m 7,092 bytes −12 formatting change so overview appears before TOC undo
• curprev 00:2400:24, 13 October 2005 Reinyday talk contribs 7,104 bytes +25 link addition undo

9 October 2005

• curprev 19:3719:37, 9 October 2005 Hiding talk contribs 7,079 bytes 0 →Procedure: tipo undo
• curprev 19:3419:34, 9 October 2005 Hiding talk contribs 7,079 bytes +1 →Proposal: tipo undo

8 October 2005

• curprev 02:4802:48, 8 October 2005 Ryan Norton talk contribs 7,078 bytes +184 →Pro: add "more knowledgable" argument undo
• curprev 02:4602:46, 8 October 2005 Ryan Norton talk contribs 6,894 bytes +308 →Pro: add subjective argument undo
• curprev 02:3102:31, 8 October 2005 Ryan Norton talk contribs 6,586 bytes −5,591 →Con: cleanup - remove duplicate arguments, merge like ones undo

7 October 2005

• curprev 22:1522:15, 7 October 2005 SimonP talk contribs 12,177 bytes +410 →Con undo
• curprev 20:4920:49, 7 October 2005 EngineerScotty talk contribs 11,767 bytes +499 →Con undo
• curprev 19:5119:51, 7 October 2005 SimonP talk contribs m 11,268 bytes +3 →Con undo
• curprev 19:5019:50, 7 October 2005 SimonP talk contribs 11,265 bytes +584 →Con undo
• curprev 19:3019:30, 7 October 2005 EngineerScotty talk contribs 10,681 bytes +2,033 →Con undo
• curprev 18:5018:50, 7 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 8,648 bytes +400 →Con undo
• curprev 18:3518:35, 7 October 2005 EngineerScotty talk contribs 8,248 bytes +1,605 →Con undo
• curprev 18:1818:18, 7 October 2005 EngineerScotty talk contribs 6,643 bytes +216 →Con undo
• curprev 17:5917:59, 7 October 2005 Lupin talk contribs 6,427 bytes +204 →Con: clarify - this would be quite close to a notability policy in terms of which articles get deleted undo
• curprev 17:5717:57, 7 October 2005 Lupin talk contribs 6,223 bytes +447 →Con: another con undo

6 October 2005

• curprev 03:2603:26, 6 October 2005 SPUI talk contribs 5,776 bytes +56 →Con: merge undo
• curprev 00:3200:32, 6 October 2005 JYolkowski talk contribs 5,720 bytes +242 →Con: +1 undo

5 October 2005

• curprev 23:5323:53, 5 October 2005 SimonP talk contribs 5,478 bytes +602 verifiable+NPOV, is the standard argument for not adding a notability requirement undo
• curprev 23:3423:34, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs m 4,876 bytes −3 →Con: correct? wording undo
• curprev 23:3223:32, 5 October 2005 JYolkowski talk contribs 4,879 bytes +44 →Pro: +(which is neither a policy nor a guideline) undo
• curprev 23:3023:30, 5 October 2005 JYolkowski talk contribs 4,835 bytes +464 →Con: flesh out some of these undo
• curprev 23:0823:08, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 4,371 bytes +1 →Pro undo
• curprev 23:0723:07, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs m 4,370 bytes −4 →Discussion undo
• curprev 23:0623:06, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs m 4,374 bytes 0 User:DESiegel/Notability proposal moved to Wikipedia:Notability proposal undo
• curprev 23:0523:05, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs m 4,374 bytes +43 →Discussion: link undo
• curprev 22:4422:44, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs m 4,331 bytes +1 →Proposal undo
• curprev 22:4322:43, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 4,330 bytes +1 →Con undo
• curprev 22:4322:43, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 4,329 bytes −1 No edit summary undo
• curprev 22:3522:35, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 4,330 bytes +1,974 No edit summary undo
• curprev 22:1322:13, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 2,356 bytes +7 No edit summary undo
• curprev 22:0722:07, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 2,349 bytes +502 No edit summary undo
• curprev 22:0722:07, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 1,847 bytes −501 No edit summary undo
• curprev 22:0622:06, 5 October 2005 DESiegel talk contribs 2,348 bytes +1 No edit summary undo