Benutzer Diskussion:Stefan Kühn/Check Wikipedia/Archiv/2009/Juli

Exclusion list

Letzter Kommentar: vor 15 Jahren2 Kommentare2 Personen sind an der Diskussion beteiligt

Hello,

I think an exclusion list (page not scanned by your script) per error will help us. Some examples (discussed on French wiki)

for error 37 when we don't want to add DEFAULTSORT on sinogrammes, kanji, ...
for error 30 when some files should not have a description (especially image links on some models named {{Infobox ...}}) ...
for links to other namespaces (on discussion page, we said that sometimes a change is needed, sometimes not)

And also for false positives fr:Travail des enfants, fr:Oiseau (squelette)

We could add these pages (after verifying them) on an exclusion list per error (like Projet:Correction syntaxique/Exclusion list/30 for error 30, ...), and your script should ignore pages listed in exclusion list. What do you think about that ?

Thanks. Al1 16:46, 1. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Hello Al1, we had in DE also a discussion about a whitelist for every error. Now you want in FR also a whitelist. I had the idea for WikiProject Check Wikipedia/Whitelist#36. In the next months I will try to make this possible. At the moment I am very busy (privat and at work). Please write the exlusions in this time in the description (like in EN). -- sk 22:36, 1. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Error 083 - possible bug (WP in Italian)

Letzter Kommentar: vor 15 Jahren2 Kommentare2 Personen sind an der Diskussion beteiligt

Hello, this short message to inform you that the Check Wikipedia script run on Wikipedia in Italian flagged for an error 083 (Headlines start with three "=" and later with level two) on the article "it:Episodi di Pocket Monsters Diamond & Pearl" where actually the first headline starts with two "=" but it is inserted within a "noinclude" pair like that: <noinclude>== Title ==</noinclude>. The article was derived by "stripping" part of the contents from a very long original one and the "noinclude" is useful for a correct handling of nested articles. IMHO, if possible and if this does not conflict with other processing of the script, the "noinclude" should be ignored so that the script detects the logically correct sequence of headline levels. Thank you very much and keep up with this precious job. -- L736E 18:46, 8. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Hello L736E, I think I need this detection of "noinclude" for other thinks. But also I think this headline inside a noinclude is a bug in the article. At the moment I have no idea, how to fix this. -- sk 21:21, 13. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Error #033

Letzter Kommentar: vor 15 Jahren4 Kommentare3 Personen sind an der Diskussion beteiligt

Hello Stefan. As far as I can see here, there is no wiki syntax routine to replace underlined text (<u>) so what is the use of this error? --Superyetkin 18:08, 13. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

See here. The underline is a tag which will not supported in the future of html. If you really need this in a article than it should stand in span. This is XHTML-conform. -- sk 21:37, 13. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

I'm sorry to interrupt. But that is bullshit. You have no right to force people to use span-tags in stead of u-tags. Mediawiki should simply keep supporting u-tags, end of story. Follow the kiss principle. -- chemiewikibm cwbm 22:31, 13. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

You can disable this check on your wiki if you don't want to use it. Just set the priority in the _xx part of the translation text. --Vina 08:51, 14. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Thanks for the clarification, Stefan. I would really appreciate it if you answered my other query about the error #003 above. Cheers! --Superyetkin 23:08, 13. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Error #040 in Japanese Wikipedia

Letzter Kommentar: vor 15 Jahren3 Kommentare2 Personen sind an der Diskussion beteiligt

Hello, Stefan!

In jawiki, there are a lot of HTML font tag, but script reports no font tag. This problem was reported until 2009-01-30 version. but it occured next 2009-02-11 version. Best regards! --Mymelo 03:30, 11. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Thanks for this info. Also in other languages there are no errors. I will check this in the script. Maybe I an fix this. -- sk 21:35, 13. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Many thanks for your comment. --Mymelo 13:40, 18. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Ok, I have change the script a little bit. No I search not only for "<font>". It will also searched for "<font ...". Maybe this help. We will see this tomorrow.

Many suggestions

Letzter Kommentar: vor 15 Jahren3 Kommentare3 Personen sind an der Diskussion beteiligt

Hello Mr. Kühn,

While editing on the French Wikipedia, I found many possible errors. I list an example of each.

HTML entity ∀ (∀) should be translated into Unicode character \u2200.
HTML entity ࢘ (࢘) should be translated into Unicode character \u0898.
Many HTML entities, like &Eacute (É), should be converted to Unicode. However,   must be excluded, since it has legitimate use. A list of such entities is given by the Web Design Group. I have the full list in a JavaScript file, I can send it to you (I use it within my Firefox extension, Weekedit). They are listed on the EN.WP : en:List of XML and HTML character entity references.
If the title of the article is PSoC, the sort key should be {{DEFAULTSORT:Psoc}}.
A category sort key with a diacritic, like [[Catégorie:Acteur français|Depardieu, Gérard]], is bad.
The wikilink [[fractale|fractales]] should be shorter : [[fractale]]s.

Regards,

Cantons-de-l'Est 03:19, 17. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

Very interesting ideas. I will try to insert this in my script. -- sk 22:01, 20. Jul. 2009 (CEST)

A comment: I don't think the last one is a good idea, because it will increase the number of false positives of a spell-checker. --129.215.104.155 12:36, 21. Jul. 2009 (CEST)